
Your well tank replacement cost will vary depending on a few key factors, such as the size and capacity of the well pressure tank.
Keep your water pressure in check
Your well pressure tank PSI should be 2 to 3 pounds per square inch lower than your cut-on setting to keep water flowing properly through your home.
Expect to pay $1,900 for well pump replacement and around $400 for a new pressure tank when repairs become too extensive to address individually.
You can check your tank pressure by turning off power, draining the system, and using a digital pressure gauge on the air valve at the top.
Hiring a local well pump repair service professional provides reliable help with diagnosing pressure issues and completing tank adjustments to keep your water system running smoothly.
The pressure of your well tank affects how water flows through your home. Pressure that’s too low can cause your water flow to stop, and pressure that’s too high can put unnecessary strain on your plumbing system. Learn how to check and adjust your well pressure to keep your showers running strong and your well repairs to a minimum.
Your well pressure tank is one of the main components of your well system and is responsible for pushing water from the tank into your home. The tank is set to a specific pressure, measured in pounds per square inch, or psi.
When the tank fills with water, the air in the tank compresses and the psi builds. When the psi hits the specified target, water stops filling the tank. Then, when a faucet is opened in your home, the water pressure that has built up in the tank pushes the water through your pipes. Once the water is pushed out, the pressure drops which activates the pump to start filling the tank again.
Your pressure tank has two settings: the cut-on pressure and the cut-off pressure. The cut-on pressure is the low setting that initiates the pump to turn on, whereas the cut-off pressure is the high setting that tells the pump to turn off.
For example, if your tank is set to 40/60, the pump will turn on when it reaches a pressure of 40 psi and turn off when it reaches 60 psi.
Most pressure tanks have three settings: 30/50, 40/60, and 50/70. The larger your tank, the higher the pressure will be. You can find out what pressure yours is set to by checking the manual of your tank.
If your tank is set to a pressure outside of these three settings, be cautious. If the pressure is set to over 70 psi it can begin to cause damage to your pipes and put strain on your plumbing system. If the pressure is too low, you’ll notice low water pressure or no water at all.
Your pressure tank for the well should always have a 20-psi difference between the cut-on and cut-off pressure.
A gap that is too large will cause your pump to cycle constantly, which can lead to earlier replacements than normal. The average cost for a well pump replacement will run you $1,900.
A gap that is too small will cause the pump to cut off before the tank can fill with water. If this happens, you’ll see a loss of water or extremely low water pressure.

You should check your well tank’s pressure during installation and at least once a year to ensure it’s working properly. You’ll need to purchase a digital pressure gauge from your local hardware store to complete the reading.
To check the pressure:
Turn off the power to your tank
Open a faucet to drain the tank by running water until the pressure reads 0 psi
Locate the air valve, also known as the Schrader valve, at the top of the tank
Take off the top cap and use your pressure gauge to see the reading

If your pressure tank settings need to be adjusted, you can do this with a:
Ruler
Measuring tape
A 3/8-inch socket
Begin by turning off the power to your pressure tank. Locate the two rods at the top of the pressure switch with springs and nuts around them.
The large rod sets the cut-in psi level
The smaller rod sets the difference between the cut-on and cut-off psi
You will only want to adjust the larger rod and leave the smaller rod as is.
To decrease the cut-in psi level, turn the nut counterclockwise. To increase the cut-in psi level, turn the nut clockwise. One full rotation of the nut will cause the cut-in level to increase or decrease by 2 to 3 psi.
For example, turning the nut one full rotation counterclockwise would cause a tank with a cut-on level of 40 to decrease to 27 to 28 psi. This will also cause the cut-off pressure to change by the same amount, ensuring that your tank levels stay 20 psi apart.
If your pressure is too high, you can run into issues with your pump and valves. High pressure will cause the pump to turn on and off too quickly and may burst valves within the tank.
When reading your pressure, if it is more than 2 to 3 psi below the cut-in level, you’ll need to bleed the tank. To bleed the tank:
Locate the pin in the center of the Schrader valve
Press this pin to release air for one or two seconds
Check the pressure reading again and repeat this process until it reaches the right psi
If your pressure setting is too low, you may be noticing extremely low water pressure throughout your home. This is due to water flowing more slowly through your pipes since there’s not enough pressure behind it.
To increase water pressure from a well, you’ll need to adjust the cut-in psi to raise the pressure. If adjusting the cut-in psi doesn’t fix the problem, it’s recommended to contact a local well pump service, as your tank may need repairs.
Common issues that can cause your tank to lose pressure include:
General leaking
Broken bladder
Pipe leaks
If the technician finds that the repairs are extensive, you may need to replace your pressure tank. The cost of a new well pressure tank averages around $400.
This service was great. My air conditioner went out during the heat spell that we had. My husband has health issues and they came out that night and at 9:30pm the air conditioner was fixed and running. We are sooo very thankful, this is the company I will be using from now on and would...
Joseph did a great job with the staircase and trim. Timely and efficient, clear communication about the work, very fair pricing. For the stairs in particular, done very skillfully in an old house (1893) in a tight spiral, and very creative with how to do the handrail. Did a nice job with...
Great experience!! Dion was prompt, professional and very polite. He is hands down the best plumber I have ever used.
Cole has been handling plumbing and general contracting for our four properties over the past three years, and he’s always done a great job. Most recently, he installed a sink and countertop in our retail store where none existed before, and it turned out exactly how we needed. He’s...
Matt is a consummate professional. The work turned out to be far more difficult than expected and rather than turn the job down, Matt rose to the occasion and completed a near impossible task. I can not recommend Greene's Plumbing Service more highly. On a scale of 1-5 I would give Matt a...
The technician was very professional and friendly. He answered all my questions and was very thorough. He left the fireplace area very clean . He inspected from the roof and advised me as to other work that might need to be done. There was no pressure there. I was very satisfied with the...
Custom Paint Jobs LLC pays attention to every detail, ensuring a job well done every time.
When we had the winter freeze, I called Quantum Waterworks Waterline & Drain Cleaning Services and within 1 hour I received an e-mail and he sent someone out the next day and he was on time, he was nice and did the job quickly and cleaned up after himself. We had a leak in our kitchen from...
From the beginning , every appointment was met with punctuality! The day of installation, they arrived on time and worked tirelessly all day until the job was finished. ( Even through a very heavy down pour) Ilia, the owner is a professional, knowledgeable, and fair man. He is absolutely, and...
The service was excellent! They gave me a quote, and had it done 4 days later. My driveway looks amazing, very professional! I would definitely recommend their service to anyone. I have had neighbors stop by and ask for their information as well.
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

Your well tank replacement cost will vary depending on a few key factors, such as the size and capacity of the well pressure tank.

Drilling a well is no small feat. You’ll need to plan for excavating, a pump, and more. This guide will help you estimate and manage your well drilling costs.

Well pump pressure helps water get where it needs to go. Learn how much pressure a well pump should have before you start adjusting.

The right pressure tank size is important for maintaining your well pressure system’s efficiency. Learn how to size a well pressure tank with these steps.

A pressure tank keeps your well system running smoothly. Follow this guide to determine the specific well pressure tank size needed for your home.

You don’t always need to leave it to the pros to set up your well pump and pressure tank. Follow this guide to learn how to do it yourself.