How To Replace a Well Pressure Tank: DIY or Hire a Pro?

Take the pressure off your wallet with a little manual labor

A man picking the right size wrench
Photo: PhotoAlto/Ezequiel Sambresqui / PhotoAlto Agency RF Collections / Getty Images
A man picking the right size wrench
Photo: PhotoAlto/Ezequiel Sambresqui / PhotoAlto Agency RF Collections / Getty Images
Gillian Beckett
Written by Gillian Beckett
Contributing Writer
Updated November 7, 2023

Difficulty

Intermediate

Perfect for handy homeowners.

Time to complete

2 hours

Cost

$100–$500

Doing the labor yourself goes a long way.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.

What you'll need:

TOOLS
  • Socket and ratchet
  • Pipe wrenches
  • Screwdriver
  • Bucket
  • Garden hose
SUPPLIES
  • New well pressure tank
  • Teflon or vinyl plumber’s tape

Does your water sound like a DJ scratching a record when you turn on the tap? Or perhaps you’re experiencing constant low water pressure throughout your home? Chances are it’s time to replace your water well pressure tank. While this may sound like a job for a professional plumber, this is also something you can do yourself at home if you’re handy with DIY plumbing. Our guide walks you through how to replace your well pressure tank at home, either on your own or with the help of a pro.

Buying Your New Well Pressure Tank

When shopping for a replacement, it’s best to choose the same well pressure tank size and brand as your old tank. This helps ensure a relatively easy installation because you’ll be using the same connections, which saves you considerable time, energy, and unnecessary stress. 

Your well pressure tank will likely be one of these three types:

  • Bladder tank: This pressure tank is among the most common and uses a bladder to pressurize air above the tank’s water.

  • Air-Over-Water tank: Consisting of a single chamber, an air-over-water tank is filled with pressurized air and water, however, there is no bladder or diaphragm separating the two.

  • Diaphragm tank: A diaphragm tank features a permanently attached barrier, which expands as water enters the tank, creating pressurized air.  

  1. Shut Off the Power

    Start by cutting the power to the well pressure tank. Switch off the main circuit breaker to the well pump from your home’s electrical panel, and turn off the electrical box located near the tank. 

  2. Drain the Water

    If your tank is waterlogged, it will make it heavy and difficult to move, so it’s important to drain it before going any further. To test if your water pressure tank is waterlogged, open the pressure release valve at the top of the tank, and use the tip of a screwdriver to press the valve down gently. If water jets out, your tank is full of water. Another option is to give your tank a couple of taps—a hollow sound means little to no water. 

    To drain your tank, attach a garden hose to the drain valve, then open the valve to release the water into a large bucket, or use the floor drain in your basement. To speed up the process, open a few faucets in your bathroom and kitchen while draining. 

  3. Disconnect the Pressure Tank

    A detailed shot of a well pressure tank
    Photo: Grigorev_Vladimir / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    Once the tank is drained, remove the pressure switch cap and disconnect the wires. Use a pipe wrench to loosen the ring nut on the union where the inlet pipe connects to the tank. Then, loosen the ring-nut union to the outlet pipe using the same process. Don’t remove the nuts as you’ll need these for securing your replacement tank.

    If your pressure tank is fastened to a concrete pad, loosen and remove the bolts with a socket and ratchet in order to lift it free.

  4. Prep the Replacement Pressure Tank

    With the old tank removed, you’ll need to get the replacement tank prepped in order to install it. If the T-junction pipe connected to the bottom of your old tank is in good shape, you can use it with your new tank. 

    Wrap the threaded end of the pipe with Teflon or vinyl plumber’s tape, then insert it into the bottom of your tank and tighten it with a pipe wrench. Make sure the end of the pipe is facing the right way, so it will connect with your home’s water line. 

    Be sure to wrap the plumber’s tape around all threaded junctions, including the inlet and outlet pipes, as you go to make connections easier.

  5. Connect the Pressure Tank

    A man checking a well pressure tank
    Photo: Grigorev_Vladimir / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    If your new pressure tank is exactly the same as your old one, replacing it will be a breeze. Position it in the same spot as your old tank and thread the inlet pipes, outlet pipes, and the water line into place, tightening them with a pipe wrench. 

    If you have a concrete pad, use a socket and ratchet to anchor bolt the tank down. With everything fastened to the tank, reconnect the wires to the pressure switch. Turn on the circuit breaker to your well pump. Allow the tank to fill with water until the pump shuts off before using your home’s faucets.

DIY vs. Hiring a Pro

Replacing a well pressure tank yourself not only gives you a chance to flex your DIY plumbing muscles but can save your wallet, too. Your only cost to replace a well pressure tank will be the price of a new one, which is around $400, on average. 

But if you’re completely new to plumbing and feel uncomfortable tackling this project yourself, look for a well pump service professional near you to ensure the job’s done right. Expect to pay between $125 and $200 for labor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Your well pressure tank is a vital part of your overall well water system. A failing well pressure tank creates inconvenient water pressure problems in your home and puts enormous pressure on your well pump. This can lead to an expensive well pump replacement and installation if not dealt with right away.   

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
Learn more about our contributor
Gillian Beckett
Written by Gillian Beckett
Contributing Writer
Gillian is a freelance writer and copy editor with more than 20 years of professional writing experience covering subjects including real estate, property development, and investing. An avid gardener living in Saskatchewan, Canada, Gillian is constantly researching the latest horticulture and landscaping trends to tackle her next DIY backyard project.
Gillian is a freelance writer and copy editor with more than 20 years of professional writing experience covering subjects including real estate, property development, and investing. An avid gardener living in Saskatchewan, Canada, Gillian is constantly researching the latest horticulture and landscaping trends to tackle her next DIY backyard project.
The homeowners guide to Wells and Pumps
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.