How To Choose the Right Size Toilet Flapper
Don’t let toilet tank leaks cause a flap
Highlights
Most toilets use a standard 2-inch flapper.
Replacing a flapper is an easy DIY job.
The age of your toilet can indicate which size flapper it takes.
Toilet flappers are rubber or plastic discs inside your toilet tanks that let water flow out of the tank and into the toilet bowl when you flush. They have to fit securely in order to keep water from continuously leaking into the bowl between flushes. That’s why the question “what size toilet flapper do I need?” is an important one to answer correctly. Here, we explain how to tell the difference between the options and how to measure to get the right size.
What Size Toilet Flapper Do I Need?
Now that you know what a toilet flapper is, it’s time to talk about size. Toilet flappers come in two sizes: 2 inches and 3 inches. Of the two, the most common flapper is the 2-inch diameter, which is also referred to as the standard size. Approximately 80 percent of toilets use a standard flapper. Three-inch flappers, or large flappers, fit the remaining 20 percent of toilets.
The size of the toilet flapper is determined by the diameter (measured distance across the widest part) of the ball that fits into the flush valve opening at the bottom of your toilet tank. Since that ball fits securely inside the drain valve opening, you can also calculate the size you need by measuring the diameter of that flush valve hole.
Toilet Flapper Size by Type
With just two sizes to choose from, identifying the toilet flapper size your toilet uses is easier than many other home repair jobs. Fixing a leaky toilet flapper is also usually a fairly easy task. You can find the size you need and replace the flapper yourself if you’re even just a little bit handy, or you can call a toilet repair pro near you for help.
| Size of Toilet Flapper | Diameter |
|---|---|
| Standard | 2 inches |
| Large | 3 inches |
Standard Toilet Flapper Dimensions
The standard toilet flapper measures 2 inches across at the ball or sealing surface, and it fits toilets that have 2-inch flush valve drains.
Large Toilet Flapper Dimensions
Large toilet flappers measure 3 inches across at the ball or sealing surface, and they fit toilet valve drains that are 3 inches in diameter.
How to Measure For the Right Size Toilet Flapper
Measuring for the size of your toilet flapper is easy: all you need to do is measure the diameter of the drain hole your flapper will cover. If it’s 2 inches in diameter, which most drain holes are, you need a standard sized, 2-inch flapper. If the drain hole measures 3 inches across, you’re in the market for a large, 3-inch flapper.
In many cases, you can look at the existing flapper and visually determine the size. If the flapper is the size of a baseball or an average orange, it’s almost certainly a 2-inch, standard flapper. If it’s the size of a softball or the average grapefruit, it’s a 3-inch, or large, flapper. Eyeballing it is a great way to estimate the size you need, but always measure to be sure you’re buying the right size and to prevent a return trip to the hardware store or home improvement center.
Some brands of flappers also have the size printed on the top, so looking at your old flapper can tell you what you need to know. And when you get to the store, you’ll find that most manufacturers clearly mark the packaging with the measurement to avoid confusion.
What to Consider Before Choosing a Toilet Flapper Size
There’s really only one thing you need to know when choosing a toilet flapper to make sure you get the right size, and that’s the size of your toilet valve.
Toilet Valve Size
Since the flapper must completely cover and seal the toilet tank valve that allows water into the bowl, the size of your toilet’s tank valve is all that matters. Get this right and buy the right flapper, and you’ll get the watertight fit your tank needs to keep the water where it should be and let it flow out on demand.
Additional Toilet Flapper Considerations
Along with flapper size, there are a few other things you’ll want to keep in mind when choosing a new toilet flapper.
Toilet Age
You might be surprised to learn that the age of your toilet can indicate which size flapper it takes. Toilets made between the years of 1950 and 2000 all take a standard 2-inch toilet flapper. Toilets made in or after 2000 may take the standard 2-inch flapper or require a large 3-inch flapper. If you have a newer toilet, especially if it has dual flush capabilities, be sure to measure for the right fit.
Flapper Frames
Toilet flappers come in different materials, and that can impact how they fit and function, and which toilets they’ll fit in. There are two common flapper materials—rubber and hard plastic.
All-rubber flappers, also called flexible frame flappers, fit most flush valve drains and can stretch to fit angled seated flush valves, odd-sized flush valves, and flush valves that don’t have an area to mount a fixed flapper attachment.
Hard plastic frames, also called solid frame flappers, can stop toilets from leaking for longer than flexible flappers, which can deteriorate faster. They don’t work with all toilets, though, so only buy them as a replacement for toilets that came with solid frame or plastic framed flappers or that the manufacturer has specified are compatible with solid frame flapper use.
Flapper Types
Flappers fit into two types: adjustable and non-adjustable. The types aren’t interchangeable, as they’re designed for specific flush capacities. Toilets with lower water needs often use adjustable flappers; toilets that use more water per flush generally need non-adjustable flappers.
The best way to determine your toilet’s flapper type is to know the flush capacity. There are four flush capacities typically sold in the United States: 5 gallons per flush and higher, 3.5 gallons per flush, 1.6 gallons per flush, and 1.28 gallons per flush. The flush capacity is usually marked on household toilets, often at the back of the bowl near where the water tank sits or inside the tank.
The age of your toilet can also be an indicator. Toilets made before 1994 are almost all high-gallon-per-flush toilets, so you’ll want to choose a non-adjustable flapper. Toilets made in or after 1994 can come in both categories, so you’ll want to verify flush capacity by comparing the date and the flush valve system. Toilets manufactured in or after 2005 are generally high-efficiency, low-flow toilets and almost exclusively require adjustable flappers.
Signs Your Toilet Flapper Is the Wrong Size
If your toilet flapper doesn’t completely seal up the valve hole, you’ll notice it or hear about it.
Flushing problems: If you don’t get enough water to clear the bowl when you flush once or if you’re noticing your toilet never quite completely flushes, you may have the wrong size toilet flapper. If it doesn’t let in enough water, you can find yourself flushing multiple times instead of just once.
Running toilet tank: Is your toilet tank constantly letting a steady stream of water into your toilet bowl? This is a sure sign your flapper isn’t properly sealing. It could be due to flapper damage or deterioration, an old or worn flapper, or a problem with the seal, but this can also signal that the flapper is the wrong size.
If you experience these issues or similar problems, consider replacing the existing flapper or calling a pro to advise you on the cause.
What to Do if You Have the Wrong Size Toilet Flapper
Having the correct sized toilet flapper is important. Incorrectly sized toilet flappers lead to wasted water from multiple flushes and toilet tanks that run all of the time, resulting in higher water bills. For these reasons, you need a flapper that fits right and completely seals.
If you’ve bought a wrong-sized toilet flapper or the flapper in your toilet doesn’t fit snuggly anymore due to age and deterioration, buy one that is the correct size. While it can be frustrating to replace a flapper that isn’t worn out, flappers are quite affordable, and you’ll save more money by not wasting water than you’ll spend to get the right-sized flapper.