How to Fix A Sink Stopper That’s Not Working

Fix a sink stopper that’s not working properly in six simple steps.

Father and son doing dishes in kitchen
Photo: MoMo Productions / DigitalVision / Getty Images
Father and son doing dishes in kitchen
Photo: MoMo Productions / DigitalVision / Getty Images
SKILL LEVEL
Simple
COMPLETION TIME
45 minutes
COST
$0 to $25
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon
What you'll need:
TOOLS
  • Pliers
  • Screwdriver
  • Wrench
  • Brush
SUPPLIES
  • Pipe joint compound
  • Plumber’s putty
  • Replacement sink stopper
  • Bucket
  • Cleaning supplies

Your sink stopper is one of the most neglected parts of your bathroom and kitchen. We all know to fix a leaky faucet or a clogged sink, but what about a sink stopper that won’t stay down or needs some wiggling to get pulled up? Luckily, sink stoppers are easy to fix on your own without spending any big bucks. Follow this step-by-step guide to fix or replace your sink stopper in less than an hour.

Prepping to Fix Your Sink Stopper

Do some background research on the type and components that go into your sink stopper before the job. Knowing the anatomy will make the process go much faster. Common types of sink stoppers include lift-and-turn, push-and-pull, toe-touch, flip-it, trip-lever, pop-up. Most household nowadays uses pop-up sink stoppers.

In general, sink stoppers are composed of the following parts:

  • Pivot rod: The rod that opens and closes the plug by moving up and down in response to the lift rod motion.

  • Lift rod: Usually located on top of the sink. Pushing or lifting the lift rod moves the pivot rod and thus opens or closes the sink stopper.

  • Extension bar or clevis strap: Links the pivot rod and lift rod.

  • Spring clip: Connects the pivot rod and extension bar.

  • Pivot nut: Secures the pivot rod to the drainpipe.

  • Gasket: A circular rubber seal between the stopper and the sink. 

  • Stopper drain: If your sink stopper comes with a built-in pivot rod, it usually also has a stopper drain.

Knowing what each part is called and looks like can make it much easier to fix the sink stopper.

  1. Identify Your Stopper

    Start with identifying what type of sink stopper you have. Look under the sink. If you see a lift rod, you have a full-assemble sink stopper. Meanwhile, a universal sink stopper does not have that assembly.

  2. Disassemble the Sink Stopper

    Close-up of plumber with wrench doing repairing work
    Photo: domin_domin / E+ / Getty Images

    Since you will be working with multiple small pieces, it’s wise to have a tray or a bucket to keep all the pieces you remove together. To disassemble a universal sink stopper, simply open it up and pull the whole piece out of the sink drain. You can usually pull it out with bare hands, or you can use channel lock pliers to remove the stopper.

    For a full assembly sink stopper, start by squeezing on the spring clip to disconnect it from the pivot rod. Next, unscrew the pivot nut and remove the plug from the sink. Next, disconnect the extension bar and lift rod. Remove the lift rod from the faucet. Make sure to mark where the extension bar connects to the pivot rod.

  3. Clean All Parts

    Soak all disassembled parts in a cleaning solution or a vinegar-water solution. Let them sit for a few minutes, then use a brush to clean each part thoroughly. Only use a soft-bristle brush to avoid damaging the parts. Wipe parts dry with a soft rag and lay them on a clean surface for inspection.

  4. Inspect the Stopper

    Now that everything has been cleaned, you can easily inspect what caused your sink stopper to malfunction. First, inspect the rubber seal (gasket) to see if there is any damage. If the gasket looks cracked, brittle, or broken, you will need to purchase a new stopper.

    Next, closely inspect the remaining parts. Look for dents, bents, chips, or stubborn rusts that you couldn’t remove. Any part that shows deformation, severe corrosion, or obvious damage should be replaced. Sometimes, it’s a better deal to purchase a whole new stopper kit or use this as the perfect opportunity to upgrade to a universal sink stopper.

  5. Reassemble the Sink Stopper

    Once everything has been cleaned and replaced, you are ready to reassemble the sink stopper. You will need some pipe joint compound and plumber’s putty for this step.

    Simply insert the stopper into the drain to replace a universal sink stopper. Apply a thin layer of joint compound on the rubber seal to ensure a stronger seal.

    To replace a full assembly sink stopper, you would also begin by inserting the sink stopper. Next, push the tailpiece up from underneath the sink as high as possible. Hold it in place, fit the drain ring from above the sink, and tighten the mounting nut underneath. Then, assemble the extension bar and pivot rod.

    Test by pulling the stopper rod. If everything was assembled correctly, the extension bar and pivot rod should move as you lift or push on the stopper rod.

  6. Test for Leaks

    Close the stopper and fill your sink with water so the bottom of the sink is submerged. Wait for a while. If the water didn’t leak away, you now have a sink stopper that’s fully functioning. Otherwise, continue to tighten the clevis and pivot nut. Then, run the water with your stopper open. If water drains fast and smoothly, your drain is in a good place. Otherwise, you might need to adjust the pivot rod to open the stopper further so water can drain.

DIY vs. Hiring a Pro

Fixing a sink stopper is an easy job to do on your own, especially if you have a universal sink stopper. However, if you’d rather have a professional takeover, that’s still an affordable option. To repair a sink stopper, look for faucet repair contractors near you. Plumbers cost $45 to $200 an hour, and a faucet repair, including repairing the sink stopper, typically costs $100 and $350.

Frequently Asked Questions

Try to tighten the clevis crew and adjust the lift rod if your sink stopper won’t stay up. Sometimes your screws became too loose over time, and as a result, there wasn’t enough resistance to keep the sink stopper up. If a damaged lift rod is the cause of the problem, you will need to replace it with a new rod.

Yes. You can replace just the stopper portion with a universal sink stopper. All you need to do is open up the existing stopper and pull it up from the drain. You should be able to remove and replace the stopper with bare hands. If the existing stopper seems to be stuck, use a pair of pliers to remove it.

Remove the plug bit either with your fingers or a pair of pliers. For extra grip, try to wear rubber gloves during the removal. Remove the stem with pliers if it doesn’t come out with the plug. Clean as thoroughly as you can, then reassemble everything. If this doesn’t work, follow the above steps and replace the plug.

Today’s standard sink stopper size is 1.5 inches. However, you can still find different sizes if your house uses an older sink stopper. Other sizes you can find in most hardware stores include one inch, 1-1/4 inch, 1-3/8 inch, 1-5/8 inch, 1-7/8 inch, 2 inch, 2-1/4 inch, 2-3/8 inch, and 2.5 inch.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to Plumbers
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
A contemporary bathroom with granite tiles and a shower
Aug 21, 2024
Aug 21, 2024
Wondering how much shower valve replacement costs? The answer is about $315 on average—but foresight and research can save you some money.
Renovated bathroom with white tile
Aug 21, 2024
Aug 21, 2024
When calculating the cost to replace a shower cartridge, you need to consider the materials and labor needed and compare it to the cost of hiring a plumber vs. DIYing. This guide will help you determine the true cost of cartridge replacement.
a vintage style bathroom with bathtub, sink, and large windows
Aug 21, 2024
Aug 21, 2024
Worried about water leaking around your toilet? You may have a faulty toilet flange. Learn more about the cost to replace a toilet flange in our guide.
Woman adjusting temperature on a radiator
Sep 16, 2024
Sep 16, 2024
Two of the most common types of radiators are steam and hot water radiators. Learn how to identify different types of radiators and their pros and cons.
The exterior of a house covered in snow
Aug 23, 2024
Aug 23, 2024
Worried about frozen pipe bursts during low temps? We’ll cover how to know if a pipe has burst, plus what to do and who to call.
Low water pressure
Jan 12, 2024
Jan 12, 2024
Is your water pressure low in your house suddenly? Use this handy guide to learn about common causes of low water pressure and how to fix it.
Share project details to get started.