Top-rated heating oil pros.

Get matched with top heating oil pros in Utica, OH

There are 3 highly-rated local heating oil pros.

Matching on Angi

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

TRUSTED BY HOMEOWNERS

Average homeowner rating star icon4.9
Average homeowner rating
Verified reviews icon37
Verified heating oil services reviews

Heating oil pros in Utica

Avatar for CARE Heating & Cooling Inc
CARE Heating & Cooling Inc
5750 Chandler Ct.
4.77(
1,083
)
Approved Pro
CARE Heating & Cooling Inc
5750 Chandler Ct.
4.77(
1,083
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
103 local quotes requested

If you are familiar with any of our advertising you know that these words are at the end of each and every one of our ads. But these eight words are more than just a slogan at CARE Heating and Cooling. They are our motto and the basis of our business philosophy, and the way we want to be remembered by you at the end of the day. From the beginning I wanted CARE be a different kind of company. After spending many years working for other heating and cooling companies, I became alarmed by the trends I was seeing in the residential heating and cooling industry. “Increase sales”, “raise your prices” and “make every employee a sales person” became the operating statements of many companies, leading to the biggest fraud of all: paying service technicians to sell replacement furnaces and air conditioners. In the 1980s a major manufacturer began to promote to its dealers a unique sales technique – have service technicians sell replacements. The rationale was that a service technician had the inherent trust of the consumer. If a repair was needed a service technician had ability to take advantage of that trust and offer to install a replacement system. This provided an immediate solution to an immediate problem that would lock out any competition, result in a much higher than normal selling price and much higher profits. Because companies make more money, a lot more in fact, selling you a new system rather than fixing the one you own this approach was widely adopted over the next couple of decades. To generate even more sales and profits many companies today apply a lot of pressure to service technicians to sell even more. Several local companies’ guidelines state specifically that a consumer is to be advised to replace their furnace if a repair, even a minor one, is needed whenever a furnace or air conditioner is over 10 years old. They set goals for their service technicians to turn at least 1 in 10 service calls into sales leads and pay them a commission when a unit is sold. Service technicians can also get caught up in the quest for more money, with some diagnosing problems that may not actually exist just to earn a commission. This is how “cat toys in furnaces” and “chipmunks with attitudes and power drills” became major problems. So what makes CARE Heating and Cooling different? It is my philosophy that we are in business not only to get new customers, but more importantly to keep them. Never will anyone in the service department profit by recommending to a consumer to replace their furnace or air conditioner. Not only do we offer free second opinions for a diagnosis of a bad compressor or heat exchanger, we will often second opinion ourselves when condemning equipment to be sure we have not made a mistake. If a mistake is made, it will be an honest one and we will stand behind everything we do. Lastly, you can trust us to offer you the lowest possible price on all services and installations we do. We are, and always will be, the best value in town. Thank you for considering CARE Heating and Cooling. Let us prove to you why you should call us “When you need a company you can trust.” Call CARE for the best possible service in central Ohio. Additional emails - service@careheatingandcooling.com, sales@careheatingandcooling.com.

"Based on advertised claims, called them to fix an AC cycling problem. Tech told me that furnace was "old" and I should replace it, and then gave me a quote on replacing the furnace motor. Neither of these issues was the problem and this type of advice was exactly what I was trying to avoid. (I own seven properties and need someone who can actually "fix" an issue, not try to upcharge me). I called them several times to protest their charge of a housecall fee and one hour labor, since they did nothing to identify or fix the problem. Told them I didn't think I should pay the excessive charge but they already had my credit card number and wouldn't cancel or adjust the charge until I was called by someone. Was told some guy named Alex would call me about it, but he never calls, even though I have called their office at least 5 times to resolve the issue. Don't use these guys, there are much better providers around."

c s on December 2022

If you are familiar with any of our advertising you know that these words are at the end of each and every one of our ads. But these eight words are more than just a slogan at CARE Heating and Cooling. They are our motto and the basis of our business philosophy, and the way we want to be remembered by you at the end of the day. From the beginning I wanted CARE be a different kind of company. After spending many years working for other heating and cooling companies, I became alarmed by the trends I was seeing in the residential heating and cooling industry. “Increase sales”, “raise your prices” and “make every employee a sales person” became the operating statements of many companies, leading to the biggest fraud of all: paying service technicians to sell replacement furnaces and air conditioners. In the 1980s a major manufacturer began to promote to its dealers a unique sales technique – have service technicians sell replacements. The rationale was that a service technician had the inherent trust of the consumer. If a repair was needed a service technician had ability to take advantage of that trust and offer to install a replacement system. This provided an immediate solution to an immediate problem that would lock out any competition, result in a much higher than normal selling price and much higher profits. Because companies make more money, a lot more in fact, selling you a new system rather than fixing the one you own this approach was widely adopted over the next couple of decades. To generate even more sales and profits many companies today apply a lot of pressure to service technicians to sell even more. Several local companies’ guidelines state specifically that a consumer is to be advised to replace their furnace if a repair, even a minor one, is needed whenever a furnace or air conditioner is over 10 years old. They set goals for their service technicians to turn at least 1 in 10 service calls into sales leads and pay them a commission when a unit is sold. Service technicians can also get caught up in the quest for more money, with some diagnosing problems that may not actually exist just to earn a commission. This is how “cat toys in furnaces” and “chipmunks with attitudes and power drills” became major problems. So what makes CARE Heating and Cooling different? It is my philosophy that we are in business not only to get new customers, but more importantly to keep them. Never will anyone in the service department profit by recommending to a consumer to replace their furnace or air conditioner. Not only do we offer free second opinions for a diagnosis of a bad compressor or heat exchanger, we will often second opinion ourselves when condemning equipment to be sure we have not made a mistake. If a mistake is made, it will be an honest one and we will stand behind everything we do. Lastly, you can trust us to offer you the lowest possible price on all services and installations we do. We are, and always will be, the best value in town. Thank you for considering CARE Heating and Cooling. Let us prove to you why you should call us “When you need a company you can trust.” Call CARE for the best possible service in central Ohio. Additional emails - service@careheatingandcooling.com, sales@careheatingandcooling.com.

"Based on advertised claims, called them to fix an AC cycling problem. Tech told me that furnace was "old" and I should replace it, and then gave me a quote on replacing the furnace motor. Neither of these issues was the problem and this type of advice was exactly what I was trying to avoid. (I own seven properties and need someone who can actually "fix" an issue, not try to upcharge me). I called them several times to protest their charge of a housecall fee and one hour labor, since they did nothing to identify or fix the problem. Told them I didn't think I should pay the excessive charge but they already had my credit card number and wouldn't cancel or adjust the charge until I was called by someone. Was told some guy named Alex would call me about it, but he never calls, even though I have called their office at least 5 times to resolve the issue. Don't use these guys, there are much better providers around."

c s on December 2022


JMSM Heating-Cooling-Cooking-Fountain-Refrigeration, LLC
P O Box 28761
4.82(
102
)
Approved Pro
JMSM Heating-Cooling-Cooking-Fountain-Refrigeration, LLC
P O Box 28761
4.82(
102
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
63 local quotes requested

JMSM HEATING-COOLING-COOKING-FOUNTAIN-REFRIGERATION LLC is owned and operated by John Smith. John provides the best quality workmanship and customer service. JMSM IS A SOLE PROPRIETOR LLC, STATE LICENSED # 45605. FINGERPRINTED AND BCI BACKGROUND CHECKED . Small company equals lower overhead, which means lower prices. SPECIALIZE IN PELLET STOVE REPAIR.ALSO RV MAINTENANCE.

"Friendly, professional, responsive, did a nice job"

Gary R on February 2025

JMSM HEATING-COOLING-COOKING-FOUNTAIN-REFRIGERATION LLC is owned and operated by John Smith. John provides the best quality workmanship and customer service. JMSM IS A SOLE PROPRIETOR LLC, STATE LICENSED # 45605. FINGERPRINTED AND BCI BACKGROUND CHECKED . Small company equals lower overhead, which means lower prices. SPECIALIZE IN PELLET STOVE REPAIR.ALSO RV MAINTENANCE.

"Friendly, professional, responsive, did a nice job"

Gary R on February 2025


Avatar for Encore Heating & Cooling
Encore Heating & Cooling
8476 National Rd. SW Suite 2
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Encore Heating & Cooling
8476 National Rd. SW Suite 2
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
22 years of experience

We are a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our major focus is on the quality our work and producing outstanding results. We are committed to creating a level of value unmatched by any of our competitors. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Good and fast response and affordable"

Paula J on December 2023

We are a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our major focus is on the quality our work and producing outstanding results. We are committed to creating a level of value unmatched by any of our competitors. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Good and fast response and affordable"

Paula J on December 2023


Avatar for Super Solutions Heating & Cooling
Super Solutions Heating & Cooling
4114 N State Route 78 NW
4.88(
106
)
Approved Pro
Super Solutions Heating & Cooling
4114 N State Route 78 NW
4.88(
106
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
19 local quotes requested

At Super Solutions Heating & Cooling, our company is based on the belief that our customers' needs are of the utmost importance. Our team is committed to meeting those needs. We welcome the opportunity to earn your trust and deliver you the best service. No job is too big or too small for our experienced team. Call today for a quote.

"I called because furnace was not working Jamie came same day I called and told me heating exchange was cracked so he suggested to put in new furnace. He came two days later and put in new furnace and air conditioner. He and his helper were very professional and done a great job . Would highly recommend Super Solutions Heating and Cooling."

Rita R on November 2024

At Super Solutions Heating & Cooling, our company is based on the belief that our customers' needs are of the utmost importance. Our team is committed to meeting those needs. We welcome the opportunity to earn your trust and deliver you the best service. No job is too big or too small for our experienced team. Call today for a quote.

"I called because furnace was not working Jamie came same day I called and told me heating exchange was cracked so he suggested to put in new furnace. He came two days later and put in new furnace and air conditioner. He and his helper were very professional and done a great job . Would highly recommend Super Solutions Heating and Cooling."

Rita R on November 2024


Avatar for Air Management Heating and Cooling, LLC
Air Management Heating and Cooling, LLC
3542 Refugee Road Southwest
4.82(
39
)
Approved Pro
Air Management Heating and Cooling, LLC
3542 Refugee Road Southwest
4.82(
39
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
17 years of experience

From the professionalism of our comfort consultants to the dedication of our field personnel, we are committed to delivering you the best service. You trust us to do our job, and we are eager to exceed your expectations, whether it�s a simple AC unit replacement or a complex furnace repair. You can rely on Air Management Heating and Cooling, LLC as your preferred HVAC company in central Ohio for all your HVAC, heating, and air conditioning, water heating, plumbing, air control and other home heating and comfort needs. We pledge to always tell you upfront the cost of the completed project and to go over any details or limitations of particular products or heating and air conditioning services.

"Very knowledgeable, very nice service person, very affordable. My wife smiled when she saw him bring in a broom and dust pan when he was done. Highly recommended."

Tom S on March 2022

From the professionalism of our comfort consultants to the dedication of our field personnel, we are committed to delivering you the best service. You trust us to do our job, and we are eager to exceed your expectations, whether it�s a simple AC unit replacement or a complex furnace repair. You can rely on Air Management Heating and Cooling, LLC as your preferred HVAC company in central Ohio for all your HVAC, heating, and air conditioning, water heating, plumbing, air control and other home heating and comfort needs. We pledge to always tell you upfront the cost of the completed project and to go over any details or limitations of particular products or heating and air conditioning services.

"Very knowledgeable, very nice service person, very affordable. My wife smiled when she saw him bring in a broom and dust pan when he was done. Highly recommended."

Tom S on March 2022


Avatar for Apex Plumbing, Heating, and Air Pros
Apex Plumbing, Heating, and Air Pros
6663 Huntley Rd Suite M
4.50(
109
)
Approved Pro
Apex Plumbing, Heating, and Air Pros
6663 Huntley Rd Suite M
4.50(
109
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
105 local quotes requested
6 years of experience

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in plumbing, electrical, heating and air and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business! Book with us online or feel free to give us a call today!

"He was professional and quick."

Patrick S on November 2024

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in plumbing, electrical, heating and air and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business! Book with us online or feel free to give us a call today!

"He was professional and quick."

Patrick S on November 2024


Caputo's Heating & Cooling
7792 Darby Rd
5.00(
15
)
Caputo's Heating & Cooling
7792 Darby Rd
5.00(
15
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

At Caputo's Heating & Cooling we specialize in everything H(heating) V(ventilation) AC(air conditioning). We are confident enough in the work that we do to offer a 2 year labor warranty on all work performed. Whether its service, repair, installation, or routine maintenance we look forward to helping any way we can. As a small local outfit with 2 licensed contractors (18 years HVAC experience between us) performing on each job we can offer great work at an honest price. We offer financing options in order to provide long term solutions on new installations which are more costly than repairs. Locally owned and operated throughout central ohio we offer a product by the name of AirEase (Lennox Brand) which was founded in Columbus Ohio almost a century ago. Our pledge to our clientele is to offer an HVAC service of such a high standard, they remain clients for life.

"They went well. Just did yearly AC/furnace check ups."

ELIZABETH A on July 2020

At Caputo's Heating & Cooling we specialize in everything H(heating) V(ventilation) AC(air conditioning). We are confident enough in the work that we do to offer a 2 year labor warranty on all work performed. Whether its service, repair, installation, or routine maintenance we look forward to helping any way we can. As a small local outfit with 2 licensed contractors (18 years HVAC experience between us) performing on each job we can offer great work at an honest price. We offer financing options in order to provide long term solutions on new installations which are more costly than repairs. Locally owned and operated throughout central ohio we offer a product by the name of AirEase (Lennox Brand) which was founded in Columbus Ohio almost a century ago. Our pledge to our clientele is to offer an HVAC service of such a high standard, they remain clients for life.

"They went well. Just did yearly AC/furnace check ups."

ELIZABETH A on July 2020


A44ordable Air & Heat
Unknown
No reviews
A44ordable Air & Heat
Unknown
No reviews
10 years of experience

Two EPA Certified HVAC Tech.subcontracting for jobs on refrigeration units. Well versed in all aspects of the job as well as residential maintenance. Prices negotiable. Accepting all major credit cards.

Two EPA Certified HVAC Tech.subcontracting for jobs on refrigeration units. Well versed in all aspects of the job as well as residential maintenance. Prices negotiable. Accepting all major credit cards.


Fuller Oil Company, Inc.
148 S. Vernon St.
No reviews
Fuller Oil Company, Inc.
148 S. Vernon St.
No reviews
67 years of experience

Fuller Oil Co. is a full service fuel oil & lubricant distributor. We have 5 full time & 1 part time employees. Our billing procedures consist of mainly 30 days charge if approved for credit, which have the choice of payment by check, cash, debit or credit card. We also offer a "Budget Plan" for Heating Oil Customers in which payments are spread out over 12 Months.

Fuller Oil Co. is a full service fuel oil & lubricant distributor. We have 5 full time & 1 part time employees. Our billing procedures consist of mainly 30 days charge if approved for credit, which have the choice of payment by check, cash, debit or credit card. We also offer a "Budget Plan" for Heating Oil Customers in which payments are spread out over 12 Months.


Delaware Heating and Cooling
325 W Main Street
No reviews
Delaware Heating and Cooling
325 W Main Street
No reviews
Free onsite estimate

We offer NO OVERTIME/AFTERHOURS PRICING!!! Flexible scheduling options(weekend & off~business hours) at no additional cost. $50 diagnostic fee,waived if repair is made at time of service.All work warrantied for one year. Serving central ohio and all surrounding counties. We also service hot water tanks and do electrical repairs. Welding,metal fabrication and repair services available.

We offer NO OVERTIME/AFTERHOURS PRICING!!! Flexible scheduling options(weekend & off~business hours) at no additional cost. $50 diagnostic fee,waived if repair is made at time of service.All work warrantied for one year. Serving central ohio and all surrounding counties. We also service hot water tanks and do electrical repairs. Welding,metal fabrication and repair services available.

Showing 1-10 of 16

Heating oil services FAQs

To buy heating oil for your house, contact local heating oil companies to compare prices and place an order once you decide on a supplier. The company will have to deliver your heating oil in a truck designed to carry and dispense heating oil safely. Call and order your heating oil early enough to have your oil delivered before you need to start using it for home heating.

On average, you’ll need about two gallons of oil per day to heat your house when it’s 50 degrees Fahrenheit outside. Most oil tank capacity is about 275 gallons, and heating your house with two gallons of oil per day will last about four and a half months. This consumption will vary depending on the climate and average temperature in your location. For example, if the winters are longer and colder where you live, you’ll probably need to refill your oil tank at least once to get through the winter.

You save money on heating oil in a few ways:

  • Make sure your home is well insulated and sealed against drafts and heat leakage.

  • Use a thermostat that’s working properly and calibrated accurately.

  • Increase energy efficiency by insulating your basement and attic.

  • Turn down your thermostat a few degrees.

  • Program your thermostat to lower the heat when you’re not home.

  • Order heating oil during the off-season when prices are likely to be lower.

Summer months tend to be when heating oil prices are lowest because of decreased demand. Buying heating oil during the off-season also prepares you for when the weather gets cold, and you need to start using the oil to heat your home. Although heating oil prices will fluctuate, it’s best to avoid purchasing between September and April, as that's the peak season for heating oil demand.

Overall, heating your home with an oil furnace tends to be less expensive than heating your home with an electric heating system. Oil heating systems stay warm for longer periods of time without drawing a constant electrical current to maintain a temperature. Plus, heating oil systems typically have a longer lifespan and lower price tag than their electrical counterparts, resulting in short- and long-term savings.

The homeowners guide to home care is here
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
modern open plan living room
Jan 28, 2025
Jan 28, 2025
Polished concrete floor costs depend on the size of the area you’re targeting and the style of concrete floor. Our guide breaks down all the cost factors.
Kitchen wood floors in a historic home
Feb 11, 2025
Feb 11, 2025
If your subfloor is damaged and you need replacement, expect the cost to replace the subfloor to run between $3 and $10 per square foot to complete the job.
A basement with concrete flooring
Jan 30, 2025
Jan 30, 2025
Pouring a new concrete floor can create new usable space for your home and raise its value. This guide breaks down what affects project costs.
Armchair and tree in house entryway
Mar 27, 2025
Mar 27, 2025
An uneven floor can be dangerous as well as annoying. Find the answer to the question “why is my floor uneven” and the solution in this helpful guide.
Cat resting in the kitchen
Mar 26, 2025
Mar 26, 2025
Has a leak or flood left you with ruined floors? Learn how to repair laminate flooring water damage to get your floor looking as good as new again.
living room with hardwood floors
Mar 23, 2025
Mar 23, 2025
If you live in a home long enough, you’ll eventually run into a creaky or squeaky floor. This guide will discuss why your floors creak and how to fix it.
Share project details to get started.