The reason salt melts ice boils down to science
The dreaded part of every snow day is putting down your hot cocoa and braving freezing temperatures to deice your driveway. Thankfully, salt makes it a bit easier.
Have you ever asked yourself, “Why does salt melt ice?” The answer is hiding in your old chemistry textbook. Let’s take a closer look at this matter of simple science.
Salt melts ice because it effectively lowers the freezing point of water, known as a freezing point depression. This causes ice on your driveway or walkway to melt, even when the temperature is lower than water’s freezing point of 32 degrees Fahrenheit.
When salt dissolves, it separates chloride and sodium ions, preventing water molecules from bonding and forming back into ice. On the average driveway, rock salt will typically decrease the freezing point of water to around 15 degrees Fahrenheit, according to the American Chemical Society. The true freezing point depends on the concentration and type of salt.
Most of the salt we use to treat our roads before a snowstorm isn’t that different from the salt we put on our popcorn. They’re both sodium chloride (NaCl). The type we put on our driveway is known as rock salt, and it’s not as pure as what’s in your kitchen (so don’t try to eat it). Some cities also use other salt mixtures, known as salt melts. These include:
Calcium chloride (CaCl₂)
Potassium chloride (KCl)
Magnesium chloride (MgCl)
Calcium chloride is less expensive and more effective than sodium chloride, so it’s a popular choice for cities or business owners that have to melt large areas of ice.
Magnesium chloride is more expensive than traditional rock salt, but it’s effective in temperatures up to negative five degrees Fahrenheit.
It’s important to note that salt can only lower the freezing point of water if it’s dissolved into the water. In other words, it can’t melt solid ice—but it can dissolve into the layer of water on top of the ice, which helps melt the ice below. There needs to be some liquid present for salt to work.
For that reason, pretreating is sometimes more effective than dumping rock salt on solid ice and hoping the sun will do you a favor. If you pretreat your driveway with salt before the temperature dips, the salt will have a chance to mix with slush before the water freezes. You can also pretreat with a salt spray solution, where the salt is already dissolved.
In the United States, the average winter day rarely falls below 15 degrees, so salt is an effective deicer. Unfortunately, it doesn’t always work well in extremely cold climates (like in Canada and Alaska) or on colder roads. As temperatures decrease, so does the solubility of salt in water. At a certain point (usually around 15 degrees Fahrenheit), the water can’t hold the salt and it will freeze.
Have you ever noticed a “bridge freezes before road” sign when you’re driving over a bridge? Bridges are usually made out of materials like steel and concrete, which are good at conducting and losing heat. They also have more surface area for heat to escape because they’re surrounded by air on every side.
If that air is frigid, the bridge will ice over more quickly than the regular road, which is holding heat from the ground. If it’s really frigid, the bridge can get so cold that salt won’t be as effective (even if salt worked on the surrounding streets).
The dangers of rock salt aren’t always apparent, but it carries an environmental risk and can even burn your pet’s paws. According to Columbia Climate School, chloride is toxic to aquatic life and runs off into lakes and groundwater, disrupting freshwater ecosystems.
It’s also rough on vegetation. There are alternative ice melts like Calcium Magnesium Acetate (CMA), but some homeowners prefer natural options including:
Alfalfa meal
Coffee grounds
Sugar beet juice
Heated snow-melting mats
Since salt can’t always melt the ice on roads in colder climates, homeowners in these areas rely heavily on plowing and sand. Sand can’t melt ice, but it can help create friction so you (and your car) won’t slip.
Ice melt works faster than rock salt and is effective for temperatures that reach -15 degrees Fahrenheit. However, it doesn’t provide traction like rock salt does, and ice melt is more expensive.
Both products contain sodium chloride, or salt, which helps melt ice faster than sugar or baking soda. Salt contains more molar mass and is more effective at lowering freezing point temperatures.
When temperatures are too cold, it can keep ice from melting, and products like ice melt and rock salt are ineffective. Water turns to ice in temperatures below 32 degrees Fahrenheit. Ice melts on its own when temperatures reach above 32 degrees Fahrenheit.
Ice melt loses effectiveness in temperatures below -25 degrees Fahrenheit, and rock salt works in temperatures 5 degrees Fahrenheit and warmer.
While most people associate defrosting icy roads with salt, you can also use sugar for a similar result. Sugar lowers the freezing point of water, melting ice in a pinch.
However, sugar doesn’t melt ice as well as salt because it doesn’t separate the water molecules as efficiently. So, if you need to quickly melt a stubborn patch of ice on your driveway or walkway, it’s best to use salt over sugar for faster results.