Water Softener vs. Water Filter: Which One Is Right for Your Home?
It all boils down to your priorities
Highlights
Water softeners get rid of hard minerals in your home’s water.
Water filters remove a wider range of contaminants from your water.
Softeners are whole-house units that use salt and resin to remove minerals.
Filters come in various sizes (including whole-house, point-of-use, refrigerator, and pitcher) and block impurities from entering your drinking water.
You can install a water softener, filter, or both, depending on your goals.
If you’re unhappy with your home’s water supply, investing in a water treatment system—like a water softener or water filter—can make all the difference. However, choosing the right type of system depends on the specific problem you’re trying to solve. To help you determine the best option, let’s compare the differences between water softeners versus water filters.
Water Softener vs. Water Filter: Key Differences
The primary difference between water softeners and water filters is their purpose. Water softeners remove hard water minerals to prevent clogged pipes, stained dishes, and dry hair and skin. In contrast, water filters remove a wide range of contaminants and impurities to produce cleaner and safer drinking water.
| Water Softeners | Water Filters |
|---|---|
| Remove hard water minerals, like calcium and magnesium | Remove sediment, heavy metals, and chemicals, like chlorine |
| Can eliminate hard water stains | Can eliminate odd tastes or smells in water |
| Can increase skin health, hair health, and laundry appearance | Can help you save money by eliminating the need for bottled water |
What Is a Water Softener?
A water softener pulls hard water minerals (namely, calcium and magnesium) out of your water supply, replacing them with “softer” ones (such as sodium or potassium). This process helps prevent hard water minerals from building up in your appliances and plumbing system, which can extend their life span. Softeners can also fix other issues caused by hard water, including dry and itchy skin, dull hair, stained dishes and glassware, and stiff laundry.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Reduces hard water stains | Runs on electricity |
| Offers better hydration for hair and skin | Requires regular salt refills |
| Protects appliances and plumbing | Produces wastewater |
Best for:
People who live in regions with hard water
Individuals with dry skin or hair
Anyone who wants to reduce wear and tear on their appliances or plumbing
Pros of Water Softeners
There are many benefits of using a water softener to treat hard water in your home. For starters, a softener helps prevent hard water residue from staining your dishes and accumulating in your sinks, toilets, and showers. On top of that, a water softener can nourish dry skin and dull hair—two common signs of hard water. It can also provide cleaner laundry that’s less likely to stiffen or fade in the washing machine.
By removing calcium and magnesium from your water, a softening system also helps prevent mineral buildup in your pipes and appliances. This offers better protection against clogging and can even help them last longer.
Cons of Water Softeners
Cost is the main drawback of a water softener. Not only do you need to factor in the price of the unit and installation from a local water softener pro, but you should also consider the ongoing expenses, including the cost of electricity. And if you choose a traditional water softener, you’ll need to refill the water softener salt every six to eight weeks.
“A water softener may reduce some contaminants in your water, but it is not meant to be a replacement for robust contaminant reduction offered by water filters.”
— Johnny Pujol, CEO and Water Expert for Tap Score Water Testing and SimpleLab, Inc., Berkeley, CA
Plus, salt-based water softeners create wastewater, which isn’t good for the environment or your wallet. They also introduce trace amounts of sodium into your water. While this is safe for many people, it’s not ideal if you’re on a low-sodium diet or have high blood pressure. In that case, you might want to consider a salt-free water softener instead.
What Is a Water Filter?
A water filter removes contaminants—such as chemicals, sediment, and heavy metals—from water, so it’s safer for human consumption. They come in a variety of sizes, ranging from pitchers to refrigerator filters to whole-house systems, and filter types, including activated carbon, reverse osmosis, and ultraviolet (UV). Some use a physical barrier to block particles and impurities, while others rely on chemical or biological processes.
Each type of water filter can get rid of specific contaminants, so it’s important to do your research before choosing one. For example, UV filters are great at killing bacteria and viruses, but they can’t remove heavy metals. If that’s important to you, you may need to look for a filtration system that includes multiple types of filters.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Can remove many contaminants | Can be expensive to purchase and run |
| May improve water’s taste and odor | Some need regular filter changes |
| Installation is often DIY-friendly | May remove beneficial minerals |
Best for:
People living in areas with poor water quality
Individuals looking for a more affordable and eco-friendlier alternative to bottled water
Households with children, older adults, or immunocompromised people
Pros of Water Filters
Water filters are designed to remove all kinds of impurities, leaving you with cleaner and healthier water. They can even make your water taste and smell better. Being able to filter your water is essential if you live in an area with poor water quality or high levels of contaminants.
Also, unlike water softeners, certain types of water filters are easy to install without professional help. Pitcher and end-of-faucet water filters, for instance, require minimal assembly.
Cons of Water Filters
While small water filters are affordable and easy to set up, large-scale filtration systems are not. For example, installing a whole-house water filter costs thousands of dollars and requires the help of a licensed plumber. They also need regular maintenance and periodic filter replacements.
Another drawback is that some hard water filters remove minerals (including calcium and magnesium) from your water supply. While this is good for homes with hard water, it might not be so beneficial if you have soft water because it strips these healthy minerals from your drinking water.
Water Softeners vs. Water Filter
Since water filtration and softener systems serve different purposes, it can be difficult to compare them. However, if you’re trying to decide between one or the other, it’s helpful to understand how they match up in key categories.
Cost: Tie
Both water filters and water softeners vary significantly in price, depending on the type and size. Water filters range from $50 for a pitcher to $4,800 for a whole-house water filtration system. Water softeners cost between $200 and $4,000 on average.
Health Benefits: Water Filter
If you want the cleanest possible water, a water filter is a better choice than a water softener. Water filtration system capabilities vary, but some types can block out sediment, chemicals, bacteria, viruses, heavy metals, and other impurities. Water softeners eliminate magnesium and calcium, which are actually beneficial to your health.
Benefits for Your Home: Water Softener
On the other hand, water softeners offer more benefits for your home. By softening your water, these devices ease the burden on your appliances and plumbing and reduce hard water stains in your kitchen and bathrooms.
Maintenance: Water Filter
Water softeners require much more frequent and involved maintenance than water filtration systems. Water softener maintenance tasks include monthly salt refills, checking the brine tank for and breaking up salt bridges, and draining and cleaning the brine tank. For the most part, the only maintenance for a water filter is regular filter replacements (every three to six months).
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, you can have both a water softener and a water filter. In fact, some manufacturers sell dual water softening and filtration systems that treat hard water and provide clean drinking water. If you’re unsure about what you need or want to discuss your options, reach out to a local water softener installation company.
On average, water softeners last between 10 and 25 years. However, your water softener’s life span will depend on a few factors, including the frequency and volume of water usage in your household. To keep a whole-house water softener in good condition, be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions when it comes to cleaning the brine tank, refilling the salt, and changing the resin.