Should I Repair or Replace my Oven?

Whether your emergency cookies aren’t baking or your broiler won’t turn on, a malfunctioning oven is a real headache. As a critical, expensive appliance in your home, deciding whether to repair or replace your oven range is a major decision. Typically, oven repairs cost under $400, which is significantly less than purchasing a new unit. However, there are certain situations where replacement is the better option—read on to learn more about these scenarios.

Is It Worth It to Repair My Oven?

The decision to replace your oven—an important, expensive appliance—is a major one. Learn when it might make more sense to complete a repair. 

How Long Do Ovens Last?

Ovens last about 15 years. Gas ovens tend to last longer than electric ones because they have fewer parts and can be easier to maintain. Gas ovens also heat up faster, putting less wear-and-tear on the components when cooking. 

To prolong the life of your oven, make sure to clean it regularly, including the range, stovetop, range hood, door gasket, and coils. You should also inspect your plug and gas line regularly.

Cost to Repair an Oven vs. Cost to Replace an Oven

The cost to repair an oven depends on a few factors, but generally runs between $150 and $350. The final cost depends on the type of oven you have and the repair needed. Always check to see if your oven is under warranty, which may cover the cost of the repair. You can also search online to see if any recalls have been issued for your model, as the manufacturer will likely pay for the replacement part or repair. 

The cost to replace an oven largely depends on the cost of your new oven—models can range from $600–$2,000, depending on style and features—but you should also factor in installation costs, which generally run between $100 and $200. 

When to Repair Your Oven

Photo: Studio4 / iStock / Getty Images

There are many instances when it’s a better choice to repair your oven range rather than replace it. Ovens are expensive appliances, but often, the repair is much less expensive than the cost of a new unit. 

You’re Still Under Warranty

If your oven range is still covered under a warranty, contact the manufacturer or store—whichever issued the warranty. Most appliance warranties last for one year and cover parts and labor for that year; more expensive units might have longer warranties. If you’re unsure if you’re still covered, it never hurts to call and check.

A Recall Has Been Issued

A recall may have been issued for the part of your oven that is broken and you might not even know about it. Do some Googling and see if others are talking about your oven model and any associated recalls. Sometimes, even if a product is not recalled, manufacturers will still perform free or low-cost out-of-warranty repairs if enough consumers have complained about the issue or filed a class-action lawsuit. In 2020, for instance, there was a class-action suit against Samsung, alleging that one of their ranges wouldn’t heat past 150 degrees. 

The Repair is DIY-Friendly

There are some repairs that are simple to do, even for homeowners without a lot of experience. Usually these repairs involve replacing a part on your oven, such as a knob or a grate, or cleaning out a clogged gas burner. Even the task of replacing the igniter on a gas range is fairly straightforward; for your safety, always unplug your range before attempting any repair. 

The Repair is Less Than a New Unit

Many repairs cost less than $500 and are often less expensive than buying a new oven range. That said, this depends largely on the model of oven you have and its age; if your range will only cost about $600 to replace and your repair is estimated at $500, it might be smart to invest in a new unit, especially if your current one is reaching the end of its life span. 

DIY vs Hiring a Pro to Repair

Replacing or cleaning small parts of an oven is usually a task any DIYer can tackle, regardless of their experience. That said, when working with an oven, be sure to unplug your range and/or turn the gas line off before attempting any repair. More complicated repairs, such as an oven that won’t heat up or a control panel failure, should be addressed by a local appliance repair company. The average cost for a professional to repair an oven is between $150 and $350.

When to Replace Your Oven

Ovens are expensive and it might always seem like the wallet-friendly option is to repair rather than replace, but if your oven is getting up there in years, you will likely save money in the long run by investing in a replacement unit.

The Repair is Over $500 for a Sub-$1,000 Unit

If you have a budget model needing extensive repair, it might be time to invest in a new unit. If your unit would cost over $1,000 to replace and the repair is less than 50% of its value, then repair is likely the best option. Make sure to get quotes from at least three nearby appliance repair companies to confirm the repair cost will be more than 50% of the price of a new unit. 

Your Oven Is At the End of Its Life Span

If the repair is more extensive than a small, inexpensive replacement part, and your oven is over 15 years old, it might be time to invest in a new unit. Otherwise, you might find yourself needing to repair it frequently as it lurches closer to appliance death. 

You Want to Switch From Gas to Electric or Vice Versa

If your malfunctioning oven is causing you trouble and you’ve been wanting to switch from a gas unit to an electric model (or vice versa), an expensive repair could be all you need to finally upgrade your entire set-up.

DIY vs. Hiring a Pro to Replace an Oven

While it’s relatively simple to install a freestanding, electric oven on your own, it’s wise to call a professional to install a gas range. Safety should always come first, and an incorrect installation of a gas appliance can lead to a fire or gas poisoning. The average gas stove installation cost ranges between $45 and $200 per hour, depending on your location.

You’ll also need to hire a pro if you have a wall unit and need to complete cabinetry work to install your new oven.