Kentucky Bluegrass vs. Tall Fescue: Which Type is Better?

Growing the greenest grass starts with choosing the right variety of seed, and if you live in a cooler climate zone, you’re likely choosing between Kentucky bluegrass vs. tall fescue. Still, while they thrive in similar climates, each has its own pros and cons, and ideal conditions for growth. Here’s a look at the differences between tall fescue vs. Kentucky bluegrass, and which will work best for your lawn. 

Kentucky Bluegrass Pros and Cons

Kentucky bluegrass is a classic type of grass that is brilliantly hued and undeniably soft, though it can be high maintenance. These are the main pros and cons of this grass.

Pros of Kentucky Bluegrass

Kentucky bluegrass is soft and vibrant, with a signature bluish-green tint that gives it its name. Highly tolerant to cold, it’s a prime choice for areas that experience frigid winters. On top of that, it’s capable of self-spreading and repairing itself from trampling feet, digging paws, and burrowing pests.

Cons of Kentucky Bluegrass

While it can self-spread to patch up bare and brown spots once it’s fully established, Kentucky bluegrass takes a while to grow. It’s high-maintenance, requiring above-average amounts of water and fertilizer treatments. Also, while it’s one of the softest types of grass out there, it’s more susceptible to being trampled, so it’s not ideal for high-traffic lawns.

Tall Fescue Pros and Cons​

Tall fescue grass is a bit rough under bare feet, but it’s fairly low-maintenance and extremely hardy. Here are the main pros and cons of tall fescue.

Pros

Tall fescue has a deep root system, making it extremely resilient against droughts and damage. It has minimal fertilization needs and average water intake, making it relatively easy to maintain. Tall fescue also has high heat tolerance and moderate shade tolerance, making it a great choice for lawns in hotter climates that might not receive full sun.

Cons

Tall fescue isn’t as tolerant to harsh cold, so it’s best for southern cool-season and transition zones. It also can’t self-spread and repair itself from damage, so you will need to reseed or budget for the cost of resodding to address any bare or brown patches.

Kentucky Bluegrass vs. Tall Fescue

Here’s a comprehensive comparison between tall fescue vs. bluegrass.

Appearance

Tall fescue is dark, true emerald green, while Kentucky bluegrass is a brighter green with a bluish-green tint. Tall fescue’s blades are thick and coarse, whereas Kentucky bluegrass has a soft, lush texture that’s especially captivating on a breezy afternoon. 

More visually appealing: Kentucky bluegrass

Softness

Kentucky bluegrass has a fine, soft texture that is much more foot-friendly than tall fescue’s coarse blades. Keep in mind that, due to its softness, Kentucky bluegrass can’t stand up to heavy foot traffic, so try not to go too far beyond your morning barefoot walks to water your garden.

Softer: Kentucky bluegrass

Foot-Traffic Tolerance

Tall fescue is thin and coarse, making its blades more resilient to foot traffic than soft, plump Kentucky bluegrass. However, tall fescue can’t self-spread and repair itself the way Kentucky bluegrass can, so you will need to add more sod or reseed your lawn to fix areas that get heavily trampled.

Higher foot traffic tolerance: Tall fescue

Cold Tolerance

Both tall fescue and Kentucky bluegrass are cool-season grasses that can withstand colder weather, but Kentucky bluegrass is much more tolerant of cold. This trait makes it ideal for northern U.S. regions that experience particularly frigid winters.

More tolerant to cold: Kentucky bluegrass

Heat Tolerance 

While Kentucky bluegrass stands up to the North’s coldest winters, extreme heat and sunshine can scorch or kill its leaves. Tall fescue is more tolerant of hot weather, making it best suited for transitional climate zones and cool-season regions with milder winters. 

More tolerant to heat: Tall fescue

Water Needs

Fescue requires at least 1 inch of water per week, which is in line with what most types of grass need. Kentucky bluegrass, on the other hand, needs an above-average amount of 1¼ to 1½ inches per week. During summer days when there’s been a dry spell from rain, both grasses may need up to 2½ inches of water per week.

More demanding watering needs: Kentucky bluegrass

Ideal Soil pH and Type

Kentucky bluegrass needs well-draining soil with a pH between 5.8 to 7.0, while tall fescue does best in rich, clay-based soils with a pH of 5.5 to 7.5. Kentucky bluegrass needs more nitrogen-based fertilizer treatments to maintain its ideal soil pH and it’s also more sensitive to soil compaction. Before you choose your grass, it’s always a good idea to have your soil tested by a local soil testing service to learn which type of grass is naturally suited for your soil type.

More adaptable to different soil types: Tall fescue

Speed of Growth

Tall fescue germinates within 7 to 21 days. Kentucky bluegrass takes longer to germinate, averaging about 10 to 21 days. Kentucky bluegrass also generally takes longer to grow and become established.

Grows faster: Tall Fescue

Sunlight Requirements

Kentucky bluegrass is a sun-loving grass that needs at least 8 hours of direct sunlight daily in order to thrive. Tall fescue is much more tolerant of shade—it actually prefers partial shade over full sun and only needs about 4 hours of sunlight per day. 

Needs more sunlight: Kentucky bluegrass

Maintenance Needs

If you have Kentucky bluegrass, you’ll need to aerate your lawn every two to three years to ensure proper soil drainage and keep your grass thriving. Tall fescue isn’t as fussy, although it benefits from an annual overseeding to keep the blades dense and vibrant.

More high-maintenance: Kentucky bluegrass

Weed Resistance

With its fine leaves and shallow root system, Kentucky bluegrass is more vulnerable to being overtaken by weeds. Tall fescue has deeper roots and can compete against any weeds that try to take over.

More resistant to weeds: Tall fescue

Susceptibility to Pests and Disease

Kentucky bluegrass and tall fescue can both play host to common lawn pests such as ants, grubs, and webworms. During hot summer days, Kentucky bluegrass becomes more susceptible to disease and weed takeovers, while tall fescue tends to be more vulnerable to fungi. To add to that, Kentucky bluegrass has a shallower root system and can easily be damaged by digging moles, voles, and grub-hungry birds.

More susceptible to pests and disease: Kentucky bluegrass