Here’s how to make the turf decision between sod and seed
Sodding offers quick grass for your yard, but it can be costly.
Seeding has a lower upfront cost and more variety.
Seeding needs more growth time and requires more upkeep.
The best option for you depends on local seasonal factors and preference.
Whether you’re looking to spruce up a lackluster lawn or start a new one from the ground up, you’re facing the age-old dilemma of sod vs. seed. While both sodding and seeding can grow the lush, healthy grass you’re after, each has its benefits and shortcomings. Let’s take a look at the differences between sod and grass seed to help you determine which will work best for your space.
Sod is essentially pre-grown rolls of grass that you have to install onto fresh soil. You can purchase sod from suppliers such as garden centers, farms, and home improvement stores. Laying sod can create an instant lawn for homeowners and offers immediate curb appeal.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Instant installation | Higher installation cost |
| Takes root within two to three weeks | Fewer grass type choices |
| Outcompetes early weed growth | Harder to grow in shaded areas |
| Low maintenance | More labor-intensive installation |
Best for: Homeowners who want quick, effective results and low maintenance upkeep
The primary benefit of installing sod in your yard is that once installed, you have a relatively picture-perfect yard. Professional sod installers can lay sod any time and during any season, although it’s easiest in the early- to mid-fall. Sod takes root much faster than grass seed, with a turnaround time of two to three weeks. Once sod flourishes, it’s low maintenance to take care of with regular mowing and watering sessions.
The downside of installing sod is that it’s a much more expensive task than planting grass seed. Sod installation costs $1,100 to $3,000, depending on your yard’s size and condition. Plus, you’ll need to hire a team of sod professionals to install it for you.
Keep in mind that sod limits the type of grasses you can plant, and it struggles to grow evenly and quickly in shaded areas.
Seeding is another option for growing grass in which you plant grass seeds to repair patches in an existing lawn or spread seeds over an entire area to completely restart a lawn. Planting seeds is an easy, low-cost way to liven up a few thin or bare spots and restore a lawn’s vibrancy.
Planting grass seed involves distributing seeds (either by hand or a push-operated broadcast spreader) that later germinate and sprout into fresh, new grass. This lawn care method is a cost-effective way to restore bare patches, such as around walkways, and expand the green space around your home.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Less expensive | Slower results |
| Wide variety of grass choices | Weed interference |
| Low-skill installation | Requires ongoing maintenance |
The major advantage of planting grass through seeding is that it’s relatively inexpensive, as it only requires purchasing enough grass seed to cover the lawn and a seed spreading device. Seeding a lawn costs $450 to $1,800, depending on the grass type and lawn size. Plus, you can choose from a seemingly endless list of grass types based on which one grows best in your climate and soil type. You can choose to DIY the seeding process, knowing that it will take longer and more manual labor, or hire a lawn seeding service to tackle it for you.
There are several limitations to planting a lawn through grass seed. One drawback is that it takes much longer for grass to grow in—typically up to two months. During the initial growing period, there’s a higher risk of weeds interfering with the process, plus it requires ongoing upkeep like watering and fertilizing.
When it comes to choosing between sod versus seed, there isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for everyone. Always take time, maintenance, and cost factors into consideration.
Sod comes pre-grown and ready to unroll into an instant carpet of healthy grass. With proper installation and care, sod can establish a thriving lawn in just two to three weeks. All it takes is a little time for the newly-laid grass to take root, then the lawn is ready for friendly get-togethers, playing fetch with Fido, and enjoying the soft blades of grass between your toes.
As for how long it takes grass seed to grow, you’ll be waiting anywhere from seven to 21 days just for the seeds to germinate. From there, it needs at least one full growing season for the grass to become established enough to withstand regular use and foot traffic.
To fix up areas of dead grass and bare soil, you’ll want to go with grass seed. Since you have to lay sod on bare soil, you’ll likely need to tear up a bunch of healthy grass just to fill in a few bare or sparse patches. Overseeding a lawn is much simpler and less invasive, whereas using sod to repair a lawn is usually excessive.
When it comes to sod versus seed in bare soil, there’s a clear winner. Sod will be much more likely to give you a healthy, thriving lawn in a single try on top of bare soil.
Grass seed can be tricky to get right the first time around; seeds can get washed away in heavy rain, eaten up by hungry birds, or blown away in one strong gust of wind. If you choose to overseed, in many cases, you’ll need to overseed more than once to fill in the gaps before you can achieve a full, healthy lawn.
If you’re looking for a certain type of grass or your lawn has specific needs (like shade-tolerant grasses or drought-tolerant varieties), grass seed offers far more variety than sod. When choosing sod, you’re limited to what the manufacturer has ready, which may or may not be ideal for your lawn’s soil and sunlight.
Sod and seed both require frequent watering during the early growing stages to establish a healthy soil. However, sod needs slightly more water at first, but after establishing, it’s more attune to drought conditions than grass. In the long run, seed needs more water to continue thriving.
Unfortunately, laying sod isn’t as simple as unrolling a green carpet. Without proper installation, sod won’t be able to take root in the soil and will quickly die. Not to mention that rolls of sod are extremely heavy, making them difficult to lift and transport. Sowing grass seeds and keeping them watered is a much simpler DIY.
If your yard has to contend with obstacles such as weeds and soil erosion, sod will probably be your best bet. Again, freshly-sown grass seeds can easily get washed away during periods of rain or flooding, so sod will be better suited for areas prone to erosion. Weeds, on the other hand, will compete with new grass seeds for soil moisture and nutrients, and they’ll usually win.
While grass seed lacks instant results, you’ll save a bundle by opting to use it for your lawn project. The average cost of sod installation is around $2,000, or between $1.20 and $2.85 per square foot. On the other hand, the average cost to seed a lawn is a bit more budget-friendly at $450 to $1,700, or about $0.10 to $0.20 per square foot.
With the money you save buying seed versus sod, you may bank enough to hire a local lawn seeding company to do the hardest part of the job for you.
The best time to spread grass seed is during late summer or early fall, allowing the seeds enough time to germinate before winter and gain the upper hand against summer weeds. Don’t seed during winter or early spring, as soil and air temperatures will be too cold to allow the grass to thrive and could kill them for good.
If half or more of your lawn consists of dead grass or weeds, it’s better to start over with laying sod. Sod is also a better choice if you prefer instant curb appeal and a quick turnaround time. Additionally, if you’re starting a brand new yard and have nothing but bare soil, sod is a better choice than seed for creating a healthy lawn.
Seeding offers more bang for your buck since it has a lower upfront cost than sodding. Seeds also come in a wider variety of grass types than sod strips and require less intensive labor to install. However, sod may offer more protection against weeds and erosion, so keep your budget, yard type, and preferred grass variety in mind before choosing.
