German Schmear vs. Whitewash: Which One Is Right for Your Brick?
Know the differences to paint a full picture
Highlights
German schmear is a permanent application that gives brick a distressed aesthetic.
Whitewash is watered-down paint, while German schmear contains mortar.
Both methods cost around $30 to DIY.
Whitewash is easier to apply, while German schmear is more labor intensive.
Imagine you want a unique look for your brick home but don’t want to cover it with paint. If you’ve been throwing around several ideas for sprucing up your exterior, German schmear and whitewash are two brick painting methods that may have come up in your research. Use this guide to compare German schmear versus whitewash and see which is better for you.
What Are the Differences Between German Schmear and Whitewash?
At a quick glance, German schmear and whitewash may seem to be one and the same; however, there are several differences worth keeping in mind. Become an expert in differentiating between the two by checking out a breakdown of German schmear versus whitewash below.
| Type of Difference | German Schmear | Whitewash |
|---|---|---|
| Materials | Mortar, water | Paint, water |
| Appearance | Uneven | Uniform |
| Style | Cottage, Craftsman | Rustic, colonial |
| Application | Difficult | Quick and easy |
| Life span | Virtually forever | 20 – 30 years |
| Cost | $30 | $30 – $45 |
German Schmear vs. Whitewash: Material Differences
First things first: There are some major differences in the types of materials used to create both brick applications.
German schmear is a combo of 70% mortar and 30% water, which—as you probably guessed—results in a thick, pastelike material. Mortar contains cement, lime, and sand for a tough final product once dry.
Whitewash is a 1:1 to 1:3 ratio of latex paint and water. The more water you add to the water-based paint, the thinner and more transparent the final coating is. If you go for a 1:1 ratio, your paint will have less transparency, but you can also dry brush or splotch the paint for a more distressed appearance.
Differences in Appearance
When debating German schmear versus whitewash for your bricks, the way each one affects the appearance of the brick may be one of the biggest determining factors in which one you end up picking. Here’s how both materials compare.
Color
German schmear comes in white or gray because of its sand and cement composition. Traditionally, whitewash is made from white latex paint and water. Sometimes, however, whitewash contains additives like earthy materials to add subtle hues of off-white, cream, or beige to the appearance of the bricks.
Texture
Since whitewash is watered-down paint, individual bricks are fairly uniform in appearance. The watered-down mixture allows for natural brick hues to peek through the white layer without coming off too strongly.
German schmear has a rougher, splotchy texture that makes each brick different from the next one. You can say goodbye to that cookie-cutter house if you opt for a German schmear. This bold texture works really nicely in homes where the brick serves as a feature wall, or it can add major character to exterior brick.
Style
Painters and DIYers traditionally use German schmear in homes with cottage, rustic, farmhouse, Craftsman, or industrial styles. Exposed wood beams are practically calling for this perfect accompaniment. And, thanks to its unique characteristics, you can even use German schmear in modern homes for a blend between modern and natural appearances.
Whitewash, on the other hand, tends to work well with a rustic, colonial, or farmhouse-style abode. Whitewash is less popular in modern homes, as it fades over time, but you can still add another coat of whitewash down the line to brighten things up.
Application Differences
Before you go with either brick technique, you’ll want to know how they compare and contrast in terms of application, life span, maintenance, and removal. The following differences may just affect your decision.
Ease of Application
German schmear is more demanding to apply than whitewash. Since whitewash is latex paint mixed with water, it’s fast and easy to whitewash brick without the help of a local painter. Simply roll the liquid across your brick surface for a quick application.
German schmear is 70% mortar, making it much thicker and, therefore, harder to apply. You’ll need more physical labor to spread the mixture, and you’ll also need a trowel or grout sponge. To achieve that thin coating, you must leave only a small amount of the mixture behind, removing any excess solution.
You may need the help of an exterior painter near you for larger surface areas if you plan on applying the German schmear method.
Removal
Whitewash is by far easier to remove than German schmear. Mortar is challenging to remove without damaging the underlying brick, whereas whitewash can be removed through chemical stripping or power washing.
Life Span and Maintenance Differences
If you tend to change your mind over time, German schmear might not be the right brick application for your home. It’s a permanent option that won’t fade over time. This permanence, however, means your bricks are easy to maintain and don’t require regular do-overs.
Whitewash has a life span of 20 to 30 years. During this time, your bricks also require minimal maintenance, though whitewash isn’t as hardy as German schmear. You’ll need to apply more whitewash once the material starts to fade if you want your home to look as good as new.
Cost Differences
Both whitewash and German schmear are significantly more affordable than the cost of painting brick. German schmear takes the (German) cake when it comes to overall cost savings if you compare exterior brick finishing prices. You could spend as little as $30 on materials to DIY either project for interior brick, but if you’re whitewashing your home’s exterior, you might spend closer to $45 on average.
DIY vs. Hiring a Pro
Whether you’re choosing to whitewash or German schmear a surface in your home, make sure you research the technique well enough to know whether you’re ready to tackle it all yourself.
Choosing to DIY will save you a ton of money, and both techniques are accessible for most homeowners. If you can mix the solution correctly and have the patience and muscle power to apply it to your surface properly, you should be all set. That said, if you’re not confident in your painting skills, it’s perfectly reasonable to call in a paint pro who can ensure the job is done quickly and as smoothly as possible (literally).
Allie Ogletree contributed to this article.
Frequently Asked Questions
No, you do not have to seal German schmear. Since the German schmear method contains mortar, the bricks are sealed beneath the mortar’s protective coating. However, you can choose to seal your brick if you want to take an extra step to protect your brick home from humidity and moisture damage.
The core ingredient for both limewash and German schmear is different. As the name suggests, limewash uses crushed limestone as a base. German schmear uses mortar as a base. Compared to German schmear, limewash doesn’t have a long life span. It only lasts between five and seven years, while German schmear is essentially permanent.
Pros recommend mixing up your German schmear formula using mortar because it sticks to bricks easily and tends to be more forgiving for first-timers trying out the technique. Technically, you can still achieve the German schmear technique using tile grout, but it may not be worth using the riskier material when they cost about the same.