Thank you for allowing me to respond. I met with the client in person this past Monday 4/21/14, and am waiting to hear back from him because I did offer to send a crew to his home to do some additional work at no charge, in the spirit of goodwill, even though it is not a warranty covered item. I would like to respond to both the complaint that the client has filed against my company along with the negative review posting that he filed at the same time he made the complaint. As the business owner, I consider the satisfaction of every client to be highly important. Although I’d like to keep my response as brief as possible, I will nonetheless have to address each of the items he raised and respond with a level of detail that will allow both this client any future prospective client the opportunity to understand the matter clearly. As a brief background, my company has been serving the area (been in business) for over 44 years with a superior reputation of high quality and customer service; and a complaint such as this along with a negative Angie’s List report is highly unusual. As a business I have the highest commitment to honest customer service. The client’s report is somewhat inaccurate in a number of areas. First, it’s important to understand that the client hired my company to perform a bath remodeling project on July 27, 2011. It is quite reasonable to conclude that the client was more than satisfied with our company, our work and the materials we used because the client placed another order for the second bathroom (master bath) in their home on September 17, 2012 – more than a year after the first bathroom. All but one of the specified items that the client is currently complaining about is in the first bathroom we remodeled. The client has alleged that my company has failed to respond after “emails, phone calls, and certified mail” yet this is simply not the case and is a false accusation and an attempt to exaggerate the issue. I did find out that the client told one of our event staff at a trade show / home show approximately three to four weeks ago that he was unhappy, but he just told the person that “I want you to know I am not happy”. The client did not ask for any response or phone call back, etc, just that he was not happy. Our event staff did not report it further because they believed the feedback was just that. On the other hand, the “normal” or reasonable way to file any complaint or concern is to either call or send a letter to our office. Our company maintains a very detailed client database that keeps track of all communication and I have confirmed that the client’s very first instance of a complaint to my office was just a little over two weeks ago. When I received the client’s letter on April 4, 2014, I began a process to meet with my staff and learn more about the matter in detail so that I could properly respond to the client. I was obviously surprised to receive a complaint about a job that was completed years ago. On April 10, 2014 I responded in writing asking the client for a meeting in person at their home to help resolve any concern they may have. The client made an appointment with me over the phone to meet with both Mr and Mrs. My production manager and I arrived on Monday, April 21, at the agreed upon time. Upon arrival, we found that the Mr was home, but the Mrs was not home to participate in this meeting. My production manager and I sincerely want to make every effort to resolve any complaint or concern. On the client’s complaint and negative review posting, the client listed the following 6 items that are of concern to them: 1. "Valve to toilet does not fully stop/shut off water." During my visit this past Monday, I explained to the client that our company did not replace the shut off valve. The original order did not include that item and it’s not reasonable to file a complaint about an item we had nothing to do with. In general, it is not normal to replace a good valve. We know it was working properly back in 2011 because we would not have been able to easily replace the toilet if the water could not have been shut off. It is certainly possible that in the years since, a small piece of sand or debris could cause the valve to be difficult to shut off completely, or perhaps the valve now needs another internal rubber washer, but the valve that does not work 100% now is in no way an item that the client should complain about and blame us for. Just because we remodeled his bathroom does not give him the right to hold us responsible for any item in the room that might go bad in the future. The client shared that he has had prior experience with getting other contractors to do free work for him when he has complained and believes that we should simply do the same. I responded that it’s not proper to replace good valves when doing a bath remodel, it would be dishonest to charge to do work that does not need to be done, and that since it was not part of the original order and he never paid us to do that work, that I respectfully disagree that we should now be accountable to replace it. 2. "Acrylic wall panels is separating in shower and tub." (both bathrooms) I observed that the caulk joint at the ceiling in two small areas has a very minor hairline crack in the caulk. It is normal for a home over a period of years to expand and contract, and caulk can not prevent this. Although this is not a warranty item, I offered to send a crew to add some additional caulk and correct this at no charge. It’s important to note that there is no way for any water to penetrate because the crack in the caulk is only located at the ceiling. This condition in no way is a result of any lack of workmanship or product failure. 3. "Surface of the tub and shower are not easy to clean as advertised." I observed that both the tub and shower are in very good condition at this time. The advertising that has been used and our sales staff do tell clients that acrylic walls and tubs are in fact easier to keep clean because they are non-porous which means that instead of having mold and mildew that has stained into grout, an acrylic system can’t have that – thereby making the system easier to keep clean. We never made any reference that you will never have to clean your bathroom again, but we do stand by our statements that an acrylic surface is in fact easier to keep clean when compared to other kinds of building materials such as fiberglass or tile/grout. Once again, this issue is also not a lack of any workmanship nor is it a product failure and is not a fair complaint from my perspective. 4. "Changing shower lights is difficult and dangerous." This complaint by the client is also unsubstantiated. The materials we use are professional grade. The recessed lights we installed in the shower and tub areas are the proper materials, and we are restricted by building codes to only use a specific kind of recessed light that is designed to be installed directly in a tub or shower (wet area). It is true that because these units must have a tempered glass lens, they are a bit more cumbersome to change out bulbs, but my company performed the installation of these properly and there is nothing wrong with them in any way. Recessed “can” style lights that are installed in the tub/shower should be a bit harder to open because they protect us from electrocution. I sincerely regret that they are not the easiest to change, but there is no alternative product for us to install. The client ordered these lights when they placed the order and we follow the terms of the contract order. 5. "Fixtures for lights and fan are cheap and poorly mounted." I respectfully disagree with this comment 100%. We purchase professional grade materials and we hire well trained and professional employees who perform the installation. The fan was installed 100% properly, the lights were installed 100% properly and both items are working properly today, they look good and based on my 30 years working at MR.FIX-IT – I am certain there is no issue with either item. 6. "Shower door has no mechanism to prevent striking wall." Once again, this item has nothing to do with our workmanship. It is true that this shower door, along with the MILLIONS of other shower doors installed across the country do not have a mechanism to stop them from opening past a certain point. The existing door opens up and stops when it touches the adjacent wall. In the years that this door has been there, the door has not damaged the wall at all. My company installed this door, but we don’t make them. I’m sorry that the client wants it to do something it can’t, but that is not any fault of my company. The workmanship is 100% correct regarding the installation. This is a high quality door and we are proud of the way it currently looks and operates. I am happy to put a small rubber adhesive bumper on the wall if that will help resolve the issue for the client. The client referenced that the door problem was promised to be fixed in 2012 and that is not true. We did speak with the client at that time and told the client that we would check with the manufacturer to see if there was anything further that could be done and if there was we would be happy to do so. There is nothing else. The door works perfectly to this day. We refuse to modify the door because that would void the warranty. All of these issues have nothing to do with our workmanship. Our company did a good job with both of the bathroom remodeling projects and I am proud of my staff that did the work. The client references that he spent $35,000 and that is not true. I’d like to correct the record that the first project in 2011 was about $13,500, and then the client hired us again to do their other bath in 2012 for less than $15,000. The two bathroom remodeling projects total less than $29,000. I know the client wants to simply harm my reputation by making unsubstantiated claims without merit, but I can not simply allow our good company to stand by and be silent about these issues. The client states that our work is guaranteed for life, but to be fair and accurate, the acrylic walls and tub/shower materials come with a lifetime material warranty, but there is not a blanket lifetime warranty – no one in the remodeling business offers such a thing. The client references that he has some knowledge about these items as he is a home inspector. We respect the client’s views, but strongly disagree with his conclusions and would like to point out that he recently retired from an honorable military/law enforcement background and over the past year or two has decided to get into the home inspector business. With complete respect, our 44 years of business and thousands of happy clients prove that our company is honorable, honest and provides good work. The client has attempted to smear our good reputation with unfair allegations and we respectfully must object. Even with all of these issues, I would still be happy to work with this client to help in any way I can, but must also stand up for what’s honest, fair, and true. Through the Angie’s List resolution process, our company was certain we were not at fault, however we were informed that if we were able to resolve the matter by doing additional work for free, and the member accepted the resolution, that the complaint would be removed. Our company, in good faith offered a number of resolutions to the client through the Angie’s List process, but were disappointed that the member either did not accept or respond to our offers. Our company genuinely wanted to resolve the matter and ensure the client was satisfied. Our history of superior customer service speaks for itself.