Minerva Appraisal, LLC

Minerva Appraisals was contracted by my moving company to perform appraisals on the items damaged by the movers. First, I am a 4th generation auctioneer and appraiser not a random Joe that thinks every antique is worth something. Minerva Appraisals missed many of the appraisals. Not missed the target, missed the side of the barn. Not just value, but elementary identification issues. For example, on a federal eagle mirror she based date on the actual mirror (the glass part) inside the frame, which was a cheap 90s replacement (the plastic kind that bends....no, really). A many centuries old water pitcher was misidentified because it wasn't magnetic so she thought that made it newer. It was BRONZE age (bronze isn't magnetic). My greatest concern here is when I questioned them, most of the items the appraiser said something to the effect of "upon further review I *insert reason* and these are worth LESS. So, even giving the benefit of the doubt and assuming the appraiser was operating in good faith, she's admitting that her appraisals don't stand up to HER OWN review??? Additionally, it was established and the appraiser stated she understood that replacement values in this claim were based on new replacement value -- she then appraised many of the very items (that by her own admission should have been new replacement value) as USED value. So far, every single item that I have challenged her on that i sent to an expert, the expert has agreed that her assessment was wrong.