McNulty Roofing & Siding Co

Scheduled an appointment for an estimate. Company was a no show.

nobody called,never use the angie list service again

Great! They stripped 3 layers of roof from a 100 year old garage. To make this more difficult, the garage was right on the rear property line, close to the neighbor's pool and surrounded by bamboo. They cut down the bamboo, protected the neighbor's property and completed the job in 2 days, I expected this to be a miserable and messy job. The roof rafters were damaged from the tree and framing repairs were performed. The base layer was cedar shakes with 2 asphalt shingle layers above. When you strip a roof like this, the debris resembles mulch. When they were done, the area around the garage was spotless, all of the nails and staples were gone and the roof looked great. These folks are incredibly hard working craftsmen. Extra touches, like laying down plywood for the dumpster to rest on to prevent damage to the driveway, were appreciated. I used McNulty to replace the roof on our home 10 years ago. Same situation where there were three roofs on a home with a lot of dormers. The price then, like now, was very fair for the work done, and the finished work was exemplary. When I called them this time for the estimate on the garage, their guy (Tommy) was at the house within 30 minutes to give me an estimate. After I told them to start, they were here within two days (as promised) and finished within 2 days (again as promised). All on a handshake. The price was exactly as quoted. I continue to unconditionally recommend McNulty Roofing to everyone.

I was satisfied with their service but my son came and inspected it and he said that he had seen beer bottle caps and all up on the roof. I liked Mr. McNulty. I had him in my home when we were going over the price and all. Overall, they had a good price and they got it done in a sufficient amount of time. I liked my conversation with Mr. McNulty prior to his workmen doing the job and I did like his service and all, but my son was a little bit picky about them because of what he had seen, but they did a nice job. They had to remove three layers of shingles so their price was excellent. The roof has already lasted for two years. I might hire them again and recommend them but my son who is in charged of my financial affairs probably would say no.

I first dealt with this provider several years ago. As a matter of fact, I made contact because of a Angie's List review. My first contact with Dennis, the owner, was over the phone. I explained a problem regarding a leak into my attic. Prior to that, I invited two other roofers to diagnose the problem and to give me an estimate to fix it. These roofers came up with an estimate of $1,300 and $3,200. The difference being the number of shingles they recommended be replaced. I called McNulty Roofing, and Dennis answered. When I described the problem he told me that I didn't have a roof problem, I have a ventilation problem. The next day he sent someone over to improve air circulation. I don't remember exactly what he charged, but is was under $400. And no more leak! Because of this favorable experience, I asked a friend, who had received several estimates to replace a very large roof, to call McNulty. The estimate was $7000 less than any other. Dennis did the job and I have a very happy friend. In September, 2013, I felt that I was due to have my roof replaced. This required the old roof be removed, per building code. I decided not to get any estimates Given McNulty's track record with me, I gave him the job. The new roof was finished within a week of my first call. Soon after we had heavy, driving rains and the roof gave me problems around the skylight over a porch. To be honest, it may have been a skylight problem and not a roof problem. Dennis accepted fully responsibility for fixing it. He returned twice more until he was satisfied. My experience when there is a problem and the source of the problem is in doubt, fingers get pointed. I didn't experience that at all.

They came (we thought) to just give an estimate for the repairs we needed, but the minute we gave him the ok (during the same visit) his guys were up on their ladder fixing the problem. They charged us a small fraction of other estimates we got, and also provided clarification on things the other companies told us and quot;hadand quot; to be done right away. Haven't had any water since!

It was a good experience. They did a good job and were quick. They were very helpful with answering questions. We were okay with them and liked them. They came when they said they would.

Very good, on time and very good person.

Work was satisfactory, performed on schedule, and within budget, a couple of minor miscommunications were resolved to the customer's satisfaction. This contractor would be my first contact for this type of work.

I call numerous times and the office kept giving me excuses and kept saying he was going to give me the estimate but he never did.

Several years, I was having a problem with leakage in my attic. I contacted two companies who recommended patching my roof. The cost to repair were quoted in the $2500.00 range. I saw McNulty on Angie's List. I called and described my problem to Dennis, the owner. He diagnosed the problem on the phone. Had nothing to do with the roof, but was a condensation problem easily fixed. Total cost $300. Problem solved and I saved over $2000. Since then, I have recommended McNulty to a friend and to my son. Both were extremely satisfied in every way. My last association with McNulty was last February. He removed and replaced my existing roof .After a heavy rain, I had a leak around a skylight. The next day Dennis sent someone to fix it. I am totally comfortable recommending him to anyone. He sticks to his word. He is knowledgeable and his crew are professional.

They were terrific. They weren't the quickest but they were meticulous and did a very nice job.

I needed to replace a badly aging roof and repair some water damage caused by a major leak in said roof. I received three estimates and decided McNulty offered the best value. I talked to Dennis a few times and he was always courteous and professional. He started the job two weeks later. The guys he had sent were very hardworking. They came early and stripped the roof down to the bare wood the first day. Also, he had a carpenter come out and replace all the rotted wood from the water leak. The second day they came and put the new roof on. The work came out really nice. It's been about a year now and I haven't had any problems or leaks. I feel that McNulty did a great job for a fair price.

Went fairly well. Son not pleased entirely.

McNulty Time terms: To begin no later than 11/26/11 (though verbally he said he expected to begin by 11/21/11) Tto end by 12/10/11contract signed 11/13/11 and he said he would start the beginning of the following week - he said he put the 26th just in case he needed more time. He did not start until after the date he was supposed to end. (note that weather was NOT an issue)I'm no roofer but the job itself appears satisfactory. And he did not finish untill January 8th, 2012. (He took a month to do a job that he said would take (and should have taken) 3 days.) He offered nothing in the way of compensation for the delay and I did not ask.After I retained his services (but before he started) I looked as Angie's list. I should have taken other reports of lack of responsiveness more seriously. The main reason I used him was that he did a siding job for me about 15 years ago. His crew also broke a sidewalk block (though they concealed the break quite well after I had already taken photos). I did not address this with them or ask for compensation. They never bothered to disclose to me that this had happened. They also left some trash around the house (I took photos before cleaning up). Coffee cups and some small pieces of roofing material and siding were left and they left the box the siding came in on my porch.

His name is Dennis. I wouldn't recommend him. It was not a good experience. The first time he was supposed to go and look at the roof and he didn't show up. He finally did come and I asked him go inside and see where the leak was coming from so that he would know where to work on the roof. He said that he wouldn't need to do that. He would fix it and asked me not to worry. He did what he thought he should do and I paid him and then 6 weeks later it started leaking again. This time I told that he needs to be sure and needs to go in and see where it's coming from. He again said that he was fine and he wouldn't need to do that. He said that it was coming in from a different side and I asked him how he would know where it is from. He asked me not to worry and he knew where it was coming from. This is the second leak and I'm going in to pay him for that. In the interim he was supposed to meet my handyman twice and he didn't show up both the times. He didn't bother to call either. My handyman was here waiting for him and I had to pay my handyman for the time. He finally showed up the third time and he never even told me the reason why he didn't come. He just did the second work now and when I get another good rain I'll see whether it comes in. I can't do my inside repair until I know that the roof is repaired. I would give him an F for his attitude of not cooperating and not showing up and not bothering to call me. It leaked again after he did the work the first time. I don't know whether it's going to continue to leak after he does the second repair. It is still leaking whether I paid a dollar or a $1000. Any dollar that one pays when the job is not done properly is too much. His quality is poor. He's not punctual at all. He missed 2 appointments and he didn't bother to call. His professionalism is totally missing.

It did take a long time to get started because the truck broke down and the windows had to be ordered. I was upset that the workers did not pick up their trash: left it on the lawn over a weekend and my grass died. They were polite on the other hand,. The person I dealt with for the estimate was not the person supervising the work. Overall I was happy with the work but if you expect prompt response to your phone calls this is not the outfit for you

Did a good job. Not responsive at all. Have to continually call. Sometimes they show up and sometimes they do not. The last time I used him he came to my house and had to order material. After missing many appointments and not returning phone calls he finally came out. I picked out a color and he was supposed to order and then come out to do the work. I called at least 10 times. I was told he ordered merchandise and lost it. I was told so many different things and promised return phone calls and to come back out. He never returned any calls or came back out.

We had used them before to replace our roof. They were able to come out quickly. They were so fair in their pricing. They were very polite. It was one of McNulty's guys that did the work. He was very professional and very quick. He did the work quickly. He didn't have to come inside to do any of the work but if he did I'm sure he would have wiped his feet. He cleaned up after himself and told me when he was done.

They were unsatisfactory. They came out and we had them replace the ventilator and fix a window. They did not fix the roof as the gutter had caused the problem and they told us to contact gutter guys. We called them and had that resolved. In the interim they tried to sell us a roof. Once we told that that we were not interested in purchasing a roof then he scheduled to do the roof we actually contacted him for. He never answered our phone calls and gave us repeated excuses. He never came to fix the roof. He was just washing his hands off as we did not buy the roof from him. His price was very high. The quality of work of what he did was okay. I would never recommend them to others though.

We found them on the list in 2007 and have been using them regularly ever since. Our house got struck by lightning in July and we were away at the time. We were really lucky because somehow it did not hit the house directly and hit the gate candle, which is right next to the house. The wood underneath the siding, you can tell is charred and must have been during the rain and it must have put it out. They came out and repaired that. The last job was about $600. He has a really good professional team and they have been the same guys for every job. They are really professional and courteous. Dennis is really responsive. They are very trustworthy and I had them go do my parents house and my dad has Alzheimer's and there are not that many people that I like to let go in and work there.

This contractor has no respect for other people's time apparently. He showed up to my house unannounced and when I wasn't there, called to ask if he could come over later that day to do the work for $200.00, even though he hadn't even seen what needed to be done. And then, he didn't even bother to show. In talking with him, I felt rushed, as though he wanted to squeeze me in somewhere just to make that extra buck. In the end, I think this contractor cares more about his bottom line than his integrity, reputation, or customers.

They got back to me within 20 minutes after I called them. I had called many companies, and they responded first. They happened to be in the area when I called, and they said that they can come the same day and finished the job. I actually sent them away because I wanted to get more quotes, but my husband asked me to go ahead with them. Their estimate was online with the other quotes we got. So it was a good experience. The cost was good, they responded immediately, and they finished the job the same day.

They were professional, responsive and they came on time. Their pricing was reasonable as well. The quality of their work was good and I was satisfied with their service.

I contacted this contracted on 8/26/09. He returned my call and set up an appointment to come to my home on 8/28/09. He said that he would call before coming out. On 8/28 at about noon, when I hadn't heard from him I call the office which referred me to his cell phone. I was able to reach him on his cell and he said he was coming out later that afternoon. Again he would call before he came out. I did not hear from him again nor did he show up to do the work. On 8/31/09, I call the office again to give him one last chance to come out later that week to do the work. The office said they would have him call me. To date, 9/3/09 at 2:45 p.m I still have not heard from the contractor.