In reference to this review, we will do our best to support our point of view with facts given from both the technicians and 2 office personnel that had conversations with the customer. The 2 technicians that were dispatched to this job both have over 15 years of experience in their trade. In those 15+ years we are unaware of any other time that these technicians have been unprofessional, rude or aggressive as this customer claims. It simply goes against their character. As we try to understand the customer's point of view, it is considered to be inaccurate. On June 7, 2016 at 4:00 PM, we went to the customer's home for the upstairs system not cooling properly. The technician found both the outdoor unit coils to be plugged with dust and dirt. (we have before and after coil cleaning pictures, proving this was necessary and not an up sell, as claimed by the customer, but do not have the ability to post here). When this happens the system gets over worked, runs a high liquid pressure and can run so high that the system develops leaks because the pressures are higher than the max rated pressure of the system. This can also cause the system to lose capacity and efficiency. The technician cleaned both outdoor coils for the price of one system and added refrigerant to both of the systems, both of which was approved by the customer. During that service we waived a second diagnostic for the downstairs ($79) system as well as the coil cleaning on the downstairs unit ($87), totaling $166 in savings for the customer, to be fair. It is also impossible to know the exact amount a system needs to be recharged to factory specs, until it is added to the system (after the coil is cleaned). There are factors that add to the total system charge. Factors like the size of the indoor coil and length of refrigerant lines (from outside, up 2 stories and into the attic) to the indoor unit. Since the technician added refrigerant to both systems and didn't go over the amount he quoted, this doesn't indicate any wrong doing, misdiagnosis, or upselling as it is impossible to know how much the system will take, especially with blocked airflow across the outdoor coil. The one thing that stands out is the fact that the technician took pictures of the outdoor coil cleaning before and after (we wish we could post here). Technicians generally only do this if they are receiving resistance from a customer. We will not say negative things about a customer, but these pictures show the coil undoubtedly needed cleaning and once cleaned should operate much better. On June 9, 2016 the customer called the office and spoke with someone in the office and also spoke with Justin. The customer explained to Justin that they have called some companies and got pricing for R-22 refrigerant and the customer feels $100 per pound is a fair price. Justin knows that some companies charge up to $300 per pound so he asked if the customer had called them as well in his pricing research, the customer indicated that they did not because they knew their pricing would be higher (this may be where they thought Justin was being rude). The customer and Justin both agreed on a $100 per pound. We then sent a check for the agreed upon difference to the customer. Justin also explained that R-22 is being phased out and the pricing keeps going up. He continued to explain that we use a 3rd party pricing software that keeps track of national averages in real time and we do not control pricing directly for refrigerant. Therefore we did not know why the pricing had gone to $140 for the first pound so he would look into it and refund the difference. The first pound costing more is because it covers the additional labor for the technician to get the refrigerant, refrigerant scale, sensors and proper tools to charge the system via superheat or sub cooling from his vehicle to the outdoor unit, it also covers the time for the system to take the refrigerant and run for at least 10 minutes for the system to equal out in pressures. This is a common practice among most companies. We use this 3rd party to keep our pricing fair for our customers by gathering the averages from other companies. The customer still however agreed to the set price when the technician was there, signed the invoice and authorized the repair and then paid for the service. This can be considered an agreeance with the pricing and services. In reference to the claim that our pricing didn't coincide with our website or Angie's List. We are unaware of ever posting pricing for refrigerant on our website or Angie's List's site. We also do not claim to price match or have a low prices guarantee. We do however work with customers in an event they feel unhappy with something. As in this case, we honored their wishes and cut them a check for the difference in an act of good faith. On June 10 at 5:22 PM the customer called in and said the system was acting up again. A female representative called him back and informed the customer that we were booked for the evening and since we were just there offered them a full refund and to call another company (this is our way of trying to cut our ties with a customer we would rather not deal with). The customer declined that and demanded we send a technician out. So we sent the on call technician out, which happened to be Justin. Due to the conversation the previous day, it was an uncomfortable situation for Justin. Justin was greeted at the door by the customer who was not friendly, to say the least. Justin went outside to the outdoor units and checked the refrigerant charge on both systems. Downstairs looked good, upstairs showed signs of being low on refrigerant charge. Justin started to add R-22 refrigerant to the system to see how it would react and while doing so the lines began to frost up. This indicates there may be an indoor airflow issue, he then went into the attic and found the blower motor not working, located the cause (a bad relay) and bypassed the relay to further diagnose. He offered to replace the board at a discounted price and the customer declined unless he did it for free, insisting we never added refrigerant in the first place. Justin went back outside and removed the additional refrigerant he put in that day and the system was operating with a similar charge as when the last technician left. There was no charge for this trip to the home. Since the system worked properly for 3 days after the initial visit it is impossible to verify if this in fact was the original and only issue. Should the technician have just sold a control board to be safe? No, he was honest and stated verbally and on the invoice, if this happens again we may need to replace that part but don't want to charge you for it if you don't need it. To the claim that the systems didn't need refrigerant or we didn't add refrigerant is not true. If that was the case he would have not charged for the refrigerant. If it were the board only, he would have charged for that as it is higher than the cost of the refrigerant. The claim that a bad board and low refrigerant have the same symptoms, this is somewhat true. A low system charge can take hours if not days to freeze up and will produce a gradual loss of airflow inside due to the coil icing over. A bad board or non-operating motor will freeze up in minutes and give no airflow to the indoors. This was not the case when the technician was there initially, even after he repaired a loose wire. Once he verified the motor was operating, he then went outside and found the system charge to be low and proceeded to add refrigerant to the system. It operated for 3 days before it stopped working. It is likely that the system had 3 problems: 1) Restricted airflow through the outdoor coil not allowing heat transfer or heat removal from the home. 2) Low refrigerant charge, causing the system not to operate at full capacity. 3) An intermittent blower relay issue (board). Which we couldn't prove upon the first visit. Since the systems are 15 years old, all of these are possible. Since the coils were so badly impacted, that helps diminish the life of the system. This review claims the downstairs system has worked well since we serviced it and it indicates that the upstairs has not. It is possible that the upstairs system has lost capacity due to age and condition as well as it has a leak and has lost some of the refrigerant again, supporting our original diagnosis. The customer still proceeded to send e-mails and call the office to complain about Justin. They were informed that Justin will be reprimanded. Then 10 months later we receive a negative review claiming that Justin is liar. Justin is well known for his honesty and integrity in his trade and his personal life. We have no other instance in 10+ years to believe he is dishonest. It is our opinion that the customer may have misunderstood what Justin was saying and was not open to hear what he had to say. He still went out and got the system running for this customer and did not charge for his service. We would be inclined to think that if the technician was that disrespectful he would have been asked leave the home. Since he wasn't, we are left to believe only what we have seen in his performance in the past and since then has had no complaints about him. This is may be an instance where we can't please everyone, or they wanted us to do work for free. We certainly haven't been in business for over decade with thousands of happy customers if this is how we conduct business. This is a case where a customer made a very uncomfortable situation for our team and we did what we could to please the customer, but sometimes that just isn't possible. The day we were informed of this review we began researching it. We called Angie's List and explained that these claims are unmerited and not fair. Angie's List told us there is nothing they would do. They recommended that we get more reviews and it would help in our overall grade. Considering we have an annual contract with Angie's List and pay monthly fees to Angie's List to be listed on their site, we would think we are their customer and expect good service. Due to the lack of support from Angie's List we will cancel our contract with Angie's List when our contract expires. When informed of this the Angie's List representative didn't seem to care. Their concern was more about us sending our customers to them to grow their customer base. As a service provider on Angie's List we pay for everything, we pay to be listed higher than non- paying contractors. We are encouraged to give discounts to their customers, pay to be in their monthly mailing and sell our services on their website. When a customer purchases a service on their site Angie's List also keeps a percentage of that service. With having to pay Angie's List monthly and for everything it makes it difficult to give customers low pricing. We wish this could have been a shorter response, but given the nature of this review and in depth opinion, we felt it necessary to explain our side to other potential customers in hopes they would understand that this is one customers' point of view and does not reflect what we do every day, nor does it represent our technicians fairly.