Find top-rated Pros in your area

Enter a zip code and get matched to businesses near you.

Benthall Brothers Inc

Siding, Gutters, Hardware & Home Improvement Stores,

About us

Whatever your needs may be, residential, commercial, new construction or remodeling, we feel confident that Benthall Brothers, Inc., with our strong tradition, quality and service will be your “one-stop-shop.” We are proud of our tradition and with the addition of Eli Benthall (third generation, grandson of Fred Benthall), we feel that our company will carry our values of integrity, quality, and service into the future.

Business highlights

81 years of trusted experience

Services we offer

Gutter repair & replacement, siding, hardware & home improvement sales, windows, doors, stone, decks & garage doors

Reviews

3.79 Reviews
Number of StarsImage of DistributionNumber of Ratings
5
44%
4
11%
3
0%
2
11%
1
33%


Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
3.7
value
4.6
professionalism
3.6
responsiveness
3.7
punctuality
3.8
Showing 1-9 of 9 reviews

Luci H.
04/2024
1.0
replacement windows
  + -1 more
They replaced windows for my niece and never fixed them. Came out to house and then never returned. BBB is not responding to complaint. Please don't recommend unless they make this right. They did some work for me on house I built and if she had talked to me I would have told her no way!
Description of Work: Replaced windows of house.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
1.0
value
3.0
professionalism
1.0
responsiveness
1.0
punctuality
3.0


Sarah M.
01/2019
1.0
siding
  + -1 more
I contacted Benthall Brothers to get a quote on residing my house and detached garage. The first time I called, it was later in the afternoon and their estimators were not available. I was told I would receive a call back within two business days. I waited about a week, and then called back only to leave another message. I did receive a callback the next morning from an estimator and booked a time for him to come out to the house for an estimate. No one kept this appointment or called to indicate there was an issue with keeping our originally scheduled time. I'll be shopping elsewhere.
Description of Work: Residing House/Garage

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
responsiveness
1.0


Leah F.
11/2017
1.0
garage doors, siding, doors
  + 1 more
They never called to say when the work would start after the time stated to order the doors (due to them not being standard size). We called them and they never returned the call so 3 weeks later we called again and again and finally went to their business and explained that we couldn't get them to return our calls and that wasn't professional. We felt bad for the office staff since they were very nice and wanted to help but they can't control the actions of the boss. When we still didn't receive a call we told them to forget the whole thing, then we get a call about a week after (2+ months too late) without any apology. Your name is benthall and you can't make one call to communicate with your customers?
Description of Work: New siding on garage, New garage door with opener and entry door.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
professionalism
1.0
responsiveness
1.0
punctuality
1.0


Mary H.
07/2014
2.0
gutter repair
  + -1 more
unknown
Description of Work: Our contractor sub out work to Benthall Brothers and purchased supplies from them. They lost our order delaying the start date. Weather played a role in the time it took to complete the job. A 1-2 week job turned into 2 months. Working short work days, taking long breaks and lunches shortened the actual time spent working on the project. They dented trim on the siding and cracked siding and bricks but did not repair it until the contractor called them to repair it. They left a mess of nails, trimmed pieces, etc. We are still finding nails everywhere after 5 months.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
3.0
professionalism
2.0
responsiveness
3.0
punctuality
1.0


Keely V.
12/2012
5.0
siding
  + -1 more
We had a storm that ripped my electric meter off the back of my house. I had an electrician that could put that back up right away, but unfotunately it also ripped off the siding and the rotted wood underneath (my house is 100 years old, had a lot of termite damage). I needed about a 2`x8` section from corner to door frame redone. Because of the storm every construction company was swamped with work. I called a bunch of people, and Benthall Brothers was one of two that called me back. He was very nice and came out the next day to look it over and give me a quote. He was honest and explained up front that it might be a couple weeks to get it done because of all the storm damage and how busy they were. He said the job itself wouldn't take long, but that getting it scheduled in and having the man power available to do it would take some time. I was frustrated by that, but very happy that he explained it up front. I signed the contract on the morning of Thursday Aug 23,2012. When I stopped by the house on Monday morning (Aug 27,2012) I found to my surprise it was done! (I had been staying at a friends house because, duh, no electricity!) I was beyond happy! Going from a couple weeks to get fixed to done in a couple days was fabulous. I would use them again and I definitely recommend this company!
Description of Work: They repaired the framing and replaced the siding on the back corner of my house (about a 2' x 8' area).

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$475

mohammed A.
11/2012
4.0
siding, gutter repair
  + 0 more
They were not so responsive. So we went with another home improvement co. Their quality and prices are Good. The siding, doors and Garage Doors are from their Co.
Description of Work: We just called in for an estimate on repairs for Siding. VC7805

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
4.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
4.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

Scott A.
10/2012
5.0
gutter repair
  + -1 more
unknown
Description of Work: Install 6 windows with Loe Acgon put trim up. Frost top and bottom on sash in one.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
3.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
4.0
punctuality
4.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$1,719.41

Margaret L.
10/2012
5.0
gutter repair, siding
  + 0 more
On initial visit, the pros and cons of various types and grades of siding were explained very clearly. Options were also discussed, in case some underboards needed replacement. An estimate was provided after I selected the various grades and qualities of materials, and some possible situations that could result in increased cost were clearly described.. The suggestion was made that larger downspouts than the existing ones be installed in order to carry away more rainwater. This was done and has proved to be an excellent idea through some recent rainstorms.. Crew arrived each day at the promised time. Crew contained people who were experts in different areas, e.g, siding, gutters. About five or six different people made up the crew through the days of service. Work was done efficiently and with minimum of disturbance to propery or neighbors. Work was completed at about the time projected. . I asked for special treatment of one downspout - done as requested. Two weeks later I changed my mind since the first idea didn't work well. The crew returned and modified the downspout as I requested, no additional charge. A walkaround was done a week or so after completion to be sure I was satisfied with the work. I was, and a check was written for the initially estimated amount - no upcharges or surprises..
Description of Work: Installed vinyl siding and new gutters and downspouts.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
4.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro
$7,500

Marilyn A.
03/2012
5.0
home improvement stores, gutter repair
  + 0 more
They were professional and they were prompt. Their pricing was good or else I would not have gone with them . They were punctual and they were quick too. They got here to do the work and did the work until it was done. I would use them again in the future.
Description of Work: I Used Benthall Brothers Inc. to install new guttering in my house.

Rating CategoryRating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0

Yes, I recommend this pro

    Contact information

    15 Read St, Evansville, IN 47710

    www.benthallbros.com/

    Licensing

    State Contractor License Requirements

    All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our State Contractor License Requirements page.

    *Contact business to see additional licenses.


    Service Categories

    Siding,
    Gutters,
    Hardware & Home Improvement Stores,
    Doors,
    Windows,
    Garage Doors,
    Decks and Porches

    FAQ

    Benthall Brothers Inc is currently rated 3.7 overall out of 5.
    No, Benthall Brothers Inc does not offer free project estimates.
    No, Benthall Brothers Inc does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
    No, Benthall Brothers Inc does not offer a senior discount.
    No, Benthall Brothers Inc does not offer emergency services.
    No, Benthall Brothers Inc does not offer warranties.
    Benthall Brothers Inc offers the following services: Gutter repair & replacement, siding, hardware & home improvement sales, windows, doors, stone, decks & garage doors

    Contact information

    15 Read St, Evansville, IN 47710

    www.benthallbros.com/