Our roof was damaged last June in a hail storm. In July of 2009 we contracted with Advantage to replace our roof. The roof was replaced in October at a cost of almost 16,000. 15745 of this was paid by our home owner's policy insurance. Included in this payment 1660 for 1581 square feet of ice and water shield. We spent the winter in our home in Florida. When we returned in May of 2010 we found that we had a leak in the ceiling of our master bedroom as a result of the leak coming in from the roof. I contacted Advantage by phone on Friday June 4th and they sent out an inspector to look over the damaged area. He transmitted the information to the company. On Friday June 11th Trish who is one of the two owners of the company she called me and said the damage is not covered under warranty because apparently the damage is attributed to an ice accumulation on the roof eventhough the work they did was installing ice and water shield...this isn't covered under warranty? Their warranty covers repairs for one year and the roof was completed in October so it is still under warranty until October of this year. She said since it wasn't covered under their warranty I would have to report this back to my insurance company and they would probably pay me for the damage. I told her I would not call them since they paid the 1660 for ice and water shield. She then had the audacity to tell me on the phone that I was unwilling to take care of my property because I was unwilling to make a claim for a loss my insurance company already paid for. I could hardly believe that the owner of this company could be so rude and continue to make no sense as to why the warranty would not cover this damage. So it was clear to me that the warranty this company gives out is meaningless. In final I would hope that my experience with Advantage and its owners would serve as a caution to others.
Description of Work: I hired them to replace our roof.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
1.0
value
1.0
professionalism
1.0
responsiveness
1.0
punctuality
1.0
$16,000
Response from ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS
I have just received notice of this post and wanted to respond immediately. We are a very respectable and highly rated company. We have been certified by the Federal Government as an SBA 8a firm and we would not have been able to obtain that particular certification if our business practices and regard for our customers were consistent with the statements the member posted. First and foremost, I regret that the member is not one of our many happy customers. Obviously, it is our customers that have made us a successful company. I have talked with member on several occasions. We replaced his roof in October 2009. We previously met with his insurance carrier and secured full approval of his roof due to hail. In June 2010, the member called my office and advised that his roof was leaking. I called him back immediately and he explained that his roof did not leak prior to him going to Florida to stay at his second home for several months. He explained that when he returned, he observed that he had interior damage, but that his roof was not leaking. I sent a repair technician to his home. Upon inspection, the repair technician informed me that the roof had previously leaked due to ice damming. When I spoke with the member again, I advised him that ice damming is considered an "Act of God" and that neither our warranty or any other roofing warranty that I am aware of, offers coverage for ice damming. The member was noticeably agitated and verbally expressed that he felt because he paid $16,000 for his roof that we should cover the damage. I explained that regardless of how much or how little someone paid us for service, they deserve to be covered under terms in our written warranty. I further explained that we replaced about 30 roofs in his subdivision all within compparable price ranges, and that we would service any of his neighbors in the same, fair way. I further explained that we maintain a written warranty so that customers have no need to wonder what their terms of coverages are and that for most customers, it provides a high level of comfort. Our warranty specifically excludes ice damming due to the fact that it is an "Act of God" and coverage is offered under all homeowner insurance policies. The member did not want to file an additional claim with his insurance company and that was perfectly understandable. However, he remained very upset that we would not repair his interior drywall. Be advised his roof was no longer leaking and was not leaking at the time we responded due to the ice melting over the previous spring; probably when he was still in Florida. Another point was brought up during my conversation with the member. He expalined that his insurance carrier paid for ice and water shield. We installed ice and water shield in all areas designated (valleys and eaves). In fact, we made the recommendation to have ice and water shield installed even though it was not present before our installation nor was it a code required item. We made the recommendation because we felt it was the best thing to install. Ice and water shield is not yet a code required item in Carmel, Indiana. It should be, but unfortunately many roofing companies do not install ice and watershield unless the insurance companies pay for it. We install this item on EVERY roof and in EVERY climate whether insurance companies pay for it or not. Again, I wish the member could be a happy customer. He advised that we should have taken care of his interior work, whether it was our fault or not, to make a happy customer because he stated that it would only be a "couple of hundred dollars." I do see his point. However, I also feel that we must always move forward in a fair way that is consistent with our warranty and also be willing to do the same for every client.
Linda C.
01/2010
5.0
roofing
+ -1 more
The rep of company worked with me and my insurance company to get the ok to do the roof because of hail damage. They worked very well with the insurance company, and the roof was replaced within 2 weeks of inital contact. I was very pleased and recommend them highly.
Description of Work: Advantage Building Contractors replaced my roof, and another family members, also. Great service, cleanup was superior, and communications with rep were very good. This is why they were contracted to replace second roof. Would use again.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$10,000
ISAIAH K.
01/2010
5.0
roofing
+ -1 more
They worked out very well for me. They did what they said they were going to do. The price was fair. When they were finished, they paid special attention to make sure everything was done correctly. They were pretty good.
Description of Work: I used Advantage Building Contractors
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
4.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
Marcia S.
10/2009
5.0
roofing, siding
+ 0 more
They gave us an estimate first and then got the job done. They did the roofing first and then a different crew came out to get the siding done. They also installed the soffits and fascia. They also replaced a part of our roof that had rotten. They did a good job. The work was related to the storm damage. The woman from Advantage Building Contractors who gave us the estimate came out to inspect the roof and the siding. She then informed us about the damage. We later on called up our insurance company to come out and evaluate the damage caused. We were pleased and the work went on very smoothly. We haven?t had any problems. They were here when they said that they would be here. The crew that came out was very fast and cleaned up well. Our insurance company took care of the price. Whatever the woman who came out to give an estimate did was really good. I will use their services in the future as well.
Description of Work: We used the services of Advantage Building Contractors in August for roofing and also for siding.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$31,000
DON & CAROL S.
10/2009
5.0
roofing, siding
+ 0 more
PERFECT!!!
Description of Work: We had hail and wind damage from the June 2 , 2009 storm that came through. The 1st inspector from our insurance comapny only agreed to replace 1/2 the roof. Advantage stoppped by our home and offerred a "free" roof inspection and then recommended we contact our insurance company and ask for a 2nd opinion. We are so thankful that Kim from Advantage took the time to look at our roof! We called our insurance company and Kim met the adjuster and walked the roof with him. He agreed that we in fact did need the entire roof replaced. Thank you kim for your professionalism.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$11,000
Mike S.
09/2009
5.0
roofing
+ -1 more
They were wonderful and did an excellent job for us. There wasn?t anything that I didn?t like about them. They came in and got our roof done with good quality. It was clean when they were finished. They came back and checked their work and made sure that everything was hooked up.
Description of Work: Advantage Building Contractors installed the roof for us during the Labor Day weekend.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$8,000
STEVE & CATHY H.
09/2009
3.0
roofing
+ -1 more
I called for several companies for estimates. One company that has an A rating on Angie's List came out and told me that I had no problems. I didn't call them, they have been going door to door in my neighborhood saying they will check roofs for hail damage. Advantage came and told us that there was hail damage all over my roof. It seemed fishy, especially after they asked who my insurance was. I chose to not get any work done. I have since had two companies come and give estimates and they stated the roof is fine. A lady from the company had approached since had she began to yell at me when I stated that I had others look at the roof and state the roof was fine. I am not sure they are the an honest company.
Description of Work: I got an estimate from them to see if I had hail damage that needed to be repaired.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
professionalism
3.0
Marley T.
07/2009
5.0
remodeling
+ -1 more
I was very pleased. When the representative first came out, several things were pointed out that other companies did not mention. I was glad to have the opportunity to weigh my options. Everything went as planned---which was much more than I expected.
Description of Work: Roofing
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$7,000
Randy S.
07/2009
5.0
equipment rentals
+ -1 more
They showed up as scheduled. Crew was very professional. I had two other companies that were on Angie's List and all three companies would have been good choices. I felt that the materials and warranties Advantage offered were better than the other two.
Description of Work: Roofing and siding
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$21,289
Bill J.
07/2009
5.0
equipment rentals
+ -1 more
I've used this company before and they are always great! Best roofing company in the area.
Description of Work: Roofing
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$15,000
Bob J.
07/2009
5.0
remodeling
+ -1 more
Tom was very helpful and knowledgeable. Advantage came highly recommended by a friend of mine who used them. I got a good deal and I have recommended them to others.
Description of Work: Siding
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$11,000
Bill J.
07/2009
5.0
siding
+ -1 more
My insurance adjuster recommended Advantage. He said that he usually doesn't recommend contractors, but he knew I was having a hard time with other contractors and he knew Advantage would take care of me because he meets with their reps all the time and sees their work. Great recommendation! Thanks!
Description of Work: Roofing and siding
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$25,000
Pat J.
07/2009
5.0
remodeling
+ -1 more
I was very impressed with the quality of work. Advantage came highly recommended and for good reason. I was very surprised that everything went better than I planned. They are definitely the "go to" company for working with insurance companies and my house looks great!
Description of Work: Roofing, siding, gutters
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$31,000
Marley T.
07/2009
5.0
roofing
+ -1 more
My roof was leaking. State Farm inspected it and said it was not due to the storms. My brother Kenny told me that Advantage had done his roof several years ago and they were very good with the insurance companies and excellent with workmanship. I called them and two other companies. Advantage was the only company who called back the same day AND showed up ON TIME the NEXT DAY. I worked with Kim. She told me not to worry because she would meet with State Farm on a reinspection. When my adjuster got here, he already knew Kim from other claims so I felt even better. When they were done, my roof was approved. They did a great job on the roof! I have never seen people take such good care of a yard during the work. I also got a special warranty because they are GAF Certified. Excellent job. I'd highly recommend them to other family members and friends.
Description of Work: Roof replacement; worked with my insurance company after I was turned down.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$12,000
Randy S.
07/2009
5.0
roofing
+ -1 more
Very organized company. Not typical for roofers. I was very pleased with how they kept me informed. I found them listed with the BBB and NRCA (National Roofing Contractors Assn). Work was definitely first class and they live up to their website motto it seems---Expect More, Get More. Try them.
Description of Work: Roofing, Siding, Gutters, Miscellaneous Screens, Painting, Drywall, Minor A/C repair
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
5.0
value
5.0
professionalism
5.0
responsiveness
5.0
punctuality
5.0
Yes, I recommend this pro
$27,000
KEITH & SHANNON K.
10/2007
2.0
remodeling, equipment rentals
+ 0 more
If only I'd checked Angie's List first! It was a comedy of errors. After the first guy to help us got fired from Advantage, the second misplaced our insurance check. The work took months to complete. They left shingles on my driveway. The gutter installers showed up on the day scheduled, but without notifying me that they were there. I was unnerved by strange men walking around in my yard (I'm a woman, and was home alone with my 2-year-old). I'm glad the dog wasn't out at the time! Later, I realized that, while the house roof was done, the shed roof was not. Examining the papers, I realized it wasn't included in the estimate (my bad for not catching it sooner, I suppose, but that's their job). They flatly refused to do an estimate on it; refused to repair it (they weren't taking any 'new' jobs); after several attempts, they still haven't even given me information on the type of shingle they used, so I can't even match it for whoever does do the work for me. Avoid them.
Description of Work: Old, hail-damaged roof removed, new roof put on house (but not on shed)!
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
quality
4.0
value
5.0
professionalism
1.0
responsiveness
2.0
punctuality
5.0
$8,000
PEG P.
06/2007
1.0
siding
+ -1 more
Rob approached us in the ambulance chaser mode, offering to help us settle our insurance claim to have our roof replaced because of hail damage. Although ultimately the claim was denied (we have State Farm), our experience with Rob was less than adequate. Rob assured us that the entire process would take 3-4 weeks. However, it took over six weeks before the insurance adjuster even came to our house. During that time, we never heard from Rob. We had to call him to find out what was going on. We got several calls from the insurance adjuster saying that Rob had canceled or postponed meetings to view the damage. Rob, however, never kept us informed of the progress. Once the claim was denied, we never heard from Rob. We had to call him to find out that the claim had been denied. This was a very frustrating experience.
Description of Work: We contracted with Advantage to serve on our behalf regarding an insurance claim for hail damage to our roof. The claims representative from Advantage Building Contractors was Rob Kohloff. The claim was denied by the insurance company, so the work was never done. Although we do not blame Advantage for the claim being denied, we were very unhappy with how Advantage (and Rob) handled this process.
Rating Category
Rating out of 5
professionalism
1.0
responsiveness
1.0
punctuality
1.0
Response from ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS
FIRST AND FOREMOST, I SINCERELY APOLOGIZE FOR ANY INCONVENIENCE YOU MAY HAVE EXPERIENCED AS A RESULT OF DOING BUSINESS WITH US. THIS IS NOT THE EXPERIENCE OF THE MAJORITY OF OUR CUSTOMERS, SO WE DEEPLY REGRET ANY UNPLEASANT OR UNFORESEEABLE SITUATION. WE ALWAYS ENCOURAGE OUR CUSTOMERS TO BE 100% COMFORTABLE WITH US BEFORE ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT. WE REGRET THAT YOU MOVED FORWARD WITH US IN A MANNER NOT CONSISTENT WITH YOUR COMFORT LEVEL; IN THE END, WE ALL SUFFER THE CONSEQUENCES. I COULD NOT CONFIRM YOUR STATEMENT REGARDING OUR REPRESENTATIVE, ROB, NOT NOTIFYING YOU OF THE STATUS OF YOUR CLAIM. I DO APOLOGIZE FOR THE LAPSE IN COMMUNICATION IF IT DID OCCUR. UNFORTUNATELY, ROB WAS RECENTLY TERMINATED. I WISH YOUR INSURANCE CLAIM HAD BEEN APPROVED. ULTIMATELY, ALTHOUGH THAT WAS NOT THE NATURE OF YOUR COMPLAINT, I'M SURE IT DID NOT HELP WITH YOUR FRUSTRATION. INSURANCE COMPANIES HAVE BEEN TAKING MUCH LONGER THAN EXPECTED TO CONDUCT INSPECTIONS, AND, AS YOU MAY KNOW, THEY HAVE BEEN REJECTING MOST RECENT CLAIMS IN THE AREA. I HOPE THIS RESPONSE SENDS A CLEAR MESSAGE TO YOU THAT WE REGRET THAT YOU HAVE NOT BEEN ONE OF OUR SATISFIED CUSTOMERS. PLEASE LET US KNOW IF THERE IS ANYTHING FURTHER WE CAN DO TO CHANGE YOUR PREVIOUS EXPERIENCE.
LAURREN B.
10/2006
5.0
siding
+ -1 more
The whole process when very well with their representative handling most of it. She coordinated most of the work with our insurance agent and our mortgage company. She was very flexible about meeting us at night after work and very good about calling us back that day. The work itself looks really nice and the workers did a great job of cleaning up and asking us where we would like things set. They were very professional. I was very worried about doing this, it seems overwhelming when you get all of the paperwork from all of the different agencies, but it has gone very smoothly and we only paid our deductible. So the price paid above is really what the work cost, but our out-of-pocket was only $1000. That said, it's hard for me to say if we got what we paid for, I really have no idea! I didn't shop around at all and I didn't really look at the numbers in the estimate because they weren't for us, they were for the insurance company. That's why I left it ''n/a''.
Description of Work: After last springs hail storms, they coordinated with our insurance company and put on new siding and a new roof. The roof was a tear off, putting on 30-year architectural shingles. The siding was replaced on three sides, including putting on new Tyvek.
All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our State Contractor License Requirements page.
*Contact business to see additional licenses.
Service Categories
Roofing,
Siding,
General Remodeling,
Rentals - Equipment
FAQ
ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS is currently rated 4.5 overall out of 5.
Monday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 AM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 AM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 AM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 AM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 AM
ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS accepts the following forms of payment: Check
No, ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS does not offer free project estimates.
No, ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
No, ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS does not offer a senior discount.
Yes, ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS offers emergency services.
No, ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS does not offer warranties.
ADVANTAGE BUILDING CONTRACTORS offers the following services: CLAIMS NEGOTIATIONS FOR COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL, AND INDUSTRIAL CLIENTS.