Gee where does one begin? Oh my. [member name removed] has painted a grievous and one sided view for the viewers out there and while this is rare because we have 1000’s of customers, from time to time I am forced into response. The facts: I was refereed to [member name removed] by her parents. Where is the bad review for the job we did for them, and their neighbor? Who knows, in retaliation she may get them to write one! Time will tell how this goes but I see what is clearly going on here and the consumer needs to be aware. When you are a contractor folks and you have been referred, and the man never leaves the job site while you are there (her father) you really try and do above and beyond. Sometimes doing a "good deed" will get you in trouble, and that’s what has happened here. How many can relate with that; doing a good deed and then paying for it? Seriously. Well this is certainly the truth concerning this situation and while I harbor no hard feelings she most certainly is liable (just as I am) for any comments made here on a public forum. What [member name removed] is not telling the general public; and what she is telling them, is the truth according to [member name removed], and from our competition who she called in to disrespect/inspect our work before we were completely done addressing issues that arose after the install because of water. I have been in business for almost 20 years. I have serviced A LOT of people in that time frame and while I am not without fault[s], I do try my best to make right or cure any defects in anything people see, or anything brought to my attention, IF THEY WILL LET ME. I couldn’t have survived this long in business if that was a fable. [member name removed] broke contract with me, not the other way around, nor did she allow us to cure anything, she chose instead to put all her stock in mouthy competition who laid a nice top coat of #11’s over all the work we had done. [member name removed] had a 20 some year old driveway it was uneven, had alligator cracking, sub base issues. The asphalt was bending, deflecting, ponding, alligator cracking everywhere, etc.etc... I told her the same as I tell anyone, "If you don’t tear this out, you will run the high risk of reflection of those cracks coming back into your new install”. The objection here was clear for me to do 2 things. #1. Save her as much $$ as I could AND #2. build her a good-solid-driveway! We spent 3 days servicing this drive. [member name removed] knew she was ordering a much thicker, coarser, less fine asphalt rock than a finished coating of aggregate. She knew because I explained it to her explicitly; advantages, disadvantages, etc.etc… [member name removed] didn't pay for 2 lifts. [member name removed] paid for one! I explicitly explained to [member name removed] that tearing it out, installing a #9 surface (base and surface all rolled together) would be appropriate for her needs and serve her well for many years to come. Needless to say this is a quite common knowledge among people who have aggregate[s] installed and I did educate her and she was aware of her options, she relied on me to tell her which way to go. I suppose not everyone understand this concept. I told her right, and in her own words she states my competition has stated “”you can use that old cracking; vertical, horizontal, transverse, alligator asphalt for good base!”” That’s not entertaining in the slightest. I don’t think she knows what she is saying but she broke contract with us, went with him and pinned up this review. I took pictures (anyone want to see them call me and I will show them to you) and I was pretty darn proud of that drive, I even posted them on a social site. So really what was her complaint in all of this if I believe I did such a good job? I will tell you because as it stands now I will not contract with her ever again nor will I pay attention to such crass as this unless I am forced; which I am addressing right now. Anyone living in Indiana for the last 2 years has to agree, we have had a tremendous amount of rain, no? We have had our fair share of trials and tribulations in this weather patterns let me tell ya. Well if you work in construction, and you are dealing with sub base issues the wet ground can make things somewhat weak, soft in many areas. This was apparent when we excavated and removed her old driveway. She had a serious wet spot that just wouldn’t dry up in that drive and it was not a discovery point until we tore out the aggregate. We dug and dug and plugged in load after load of stone in that area. Spent a better part of one day getting compaction. It helped for sure but she had a wet spring underneath or a vein where water kept coming up and it kept raining. It’s rare but explains why her driveway had the issues it did in the worst area[s] for sure. It wasn’t sinking or anything, far from it. It was a solid driveway when we were done besides a few soft spots and a crack. We did everything as we were supposed to do. Oh there was a 2” crack in the middle of it because water was coming up through the gravel and in our hot asphalt when we rolled it, and it was something she said she never even noticed. How did she even come to notice this crack? I will tell you folks. I was transparent and brought it to her attention. That’s how she got her discovery. I told her! Yes, I brought it to her attention and the resolve. I also explained everything to her we had battled. It was in this conversation that [member name removed] pointed out she didn’t like the coarse size aggregate either, after the install. I reminded her again of the sealant application and how that would address the coarse aggregate 100%. I tell anyone who chooses (which she chose) a better binder over a pretty one that just doesn’t last as long. I explained to her again that she has a solid base finish coat; #9 and #11 surface all rolled together, so that the issue of being coarse when she chose to seal it with lots of sand would disappear, remedy and alleviate and end those concerns! That was something I reiterated and something I told her in the beginning and one of the selling points to choosing the asphalt she did. I told her I would do that for free and hot tar the 2” crack to fix it all up. That was one option. I made concession after concession to her and then the 2nd option I offered her was the most expensive to me in that I would overlay the entire driveway with finder asphalt and not charge her any monies for any labor or time, I just asked her to just pay for the asphalt materials and I would overlay and “lift the entire drive with a finishing binder coat at 1.5”. She went with this option to repave the entire driveway with #11 asphalt binder, give it one more lift to compliment her nice sub base and #9 surface install! Thats right folks, we came to terms, agreed to getting it done and she would have only paid about 900 for a second lift! We agreed after things dried out because we were dealing with so much rain. Well folks before I could even get her serviced she emailed me and said “I have had a second opinion on the asphalt job you did for me from one of your competitors and I have decided to go with them.” Dear reader, it’s at that point she crossed the line with us. She broke resolve and contract with me and I curled my nose and walked away. The damage was done. Trust me when I tell you she is a victim of her own demise and expense. I did everything I could to appease this situation and for a good deed and a solid resolve I have been nailed here with this crass. [member name removed], I am sure in your work field I can go to your competition and ask all kinds of nastiness or get them to say anything and I am sure they will if it means getting into your wallet! That is as unprofessional as it comes. You dearie have been had but not by me. I assure you. I did all the work on that drive and you let someone with their mouth run us down, and you went with them? I am sorry you were upset, you didn’t show it and we came to terms. Folks, asphalt and sealants are dependent on weather, many circumstances outside of our control can make for issues, but you work through them with your contractor and for the most part that has always worked for me and them. I am not the villain this woman has made me out to be. I have 3 children, been married to the same women for 21 years, one child in college, worked my way to my ground with my wife (wasn’t given to us) and have the good people of Bloomington to thank for helping us get here! I am here because of good work, good ethics, not the picture this women is painting who is a mouth piece for someone else. I considered sending her a letter from my attorney but you know, I am not wrong, I am not offended… it’s just not worth it. She states in her own words that bad asphalt (such as she had) didn’t need to be excavated out, it made “GOOD BASE”. Well that in and of itself should say it all for anyone that knows about construction and sub base where asphalt is cracking, alligator looking, vertical horizontal and transverse cracks are taking place. I don’t know one contractor in this world who would say such a thing, especially when they didn’t even look at it! No not one. Sorry you all had to hear and see this, I am still at a loss for what to tell people like this. I have learned you just move on. If you are reading this and you have a similar attitude like this lady, please call someone else. No offense intended. If however you are the type of person that understands things happen, get in the way or can cause havoc and you are sensible enough to allow that person to actually finish out their work, and agree and follow thru to allow the things you authorize “before you state someone else’s opinion rather than your own”, well then you may most certainly call me anytime, and you will be SUPER SATISFIED. I PROMISE! No “one person’s competition” is going to say ANYTHING NICE about the other, it’s the other way around and it is the world we live in and it’s a lesson [member name removed] has learned on her own dime. I did her right, she couldn't see.