5 Warning Signs You Have a Broken Garage Door

A broken garage door is inconvenient, but it can also leave your home unsecured

white brick house with white garage
Photo: marchello74 / iStock / Getty Images
white brick house with white garage
Photo: marchello74 / iStock / Getty Images
Highlights
  • Inspect the springs for signs of wear-and-tear.

  • Check the tracks and rollers for damage and obstruction.

  • You should hire a pro to repair or replace your garage door

  • Lubricating all metal parts of your door could fix the issue.

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

So, you just got into your car to leave the house, only to discover that your garage door isn’t working properly? A broken garage door isn’t just inconvenient; it also presents a security problem. It’s important to know how to inspect your garage door, so you can catch small issues before they become serious problems.

If your garage door is at risk of failing, there are a few red flags to watch for that could help you identify a broken garage door before it becomes a serious issue.

1. The Garage Door Takes Too Long to Open

Most garage doors have one of two types of springs: torsion or extension springs. Because we use our garage doors multiple times a day, every day, it’s normal for these springs to lose their tension. If your garage door is taking longer than a few seconds to open, inspect the springs for signs of wear-and-tear. If they’re corroded or worn down, it may simply be time to replace the garage door springs. 

It’s also normal for other parts of your door to become worn over time. Try lubricating all tracks, hinges, and brackets, as well as the springs (if they’re not visibly damaged, of course). If this doesn’t do the trick, it’s time to call a professional. We must stress that garage springs are under a lot of tension, meaning they can be very dangerous to repair. Always call a garage door installer near you to handle garage door spring repairs.

2. The Garage Door Won’t Open or Close

opening garage door with remote
Photo: mirsad / Adobe Stock

If your door won’t open or close at all, the culprit could be worn-out or broken springs, but there are a host of other reasons why this issue arises. Here are some ways to troubleshoot your garage door if it’s not opening or closing properly:

  • Check the sensors to make sure they’re in proper alignment and nothing is blocking them. Consider organizing your garage to make sure storage solutions and debris don’t routinely get in the way of the sensors.

  • Check the tracks for damage or obstructions. 

  • Inspect the rollers and lubricate them as needed. 

  • Make sure the batteries in your remote aren’t dead.

  • If the garage door opener isn’t working, first check it to make sure it’s getting power.

  • If you have insulated your garage door, check to see if your springs need to be adjusted to account for the additional weight.

3. The Garage Door Opens or Closes—on Its Own

Creepy, right? If your garage door is opening and closing all by itself, it’s likely due to one of the following reasons:

  • Your door is picking up wireless signals from a neighbor.

  • The circuit board is malfunctioning.

  • You need to adjust the limit settings. 

  • The control buttons are stuck.

While it’s not a foregone conclusion that you’ll need a new door if it’s opening and closing on its own, this could very well be the case. It’s worth consulting with a garage door professional to help you troubleshoot the issue and find the best solution.

4. You Hear Strange Sounds Coming From the Door

cable operated garage door
Photo: Octavian / Adobe Stock

First, try to identify the type of noise. Is it squeaky or grinding? If so, you can probably silence the squeaks with some lubricant—make sure your rollers and tracks are well-greased.

Do you hear a loud popping or rattling sound? This could be because a nut, bolt, or screw has become loose, in which case you can tighten this hardware yourself. 

However, the sound could be coming from your garage’s spring system, and you should 

never try to repair or adjust the springs yourself. 

Especially if you’ve already tried lubricating the metal parts of the door and it’s still making loud noises, it’s likely time to contact an expert.

5. You Can See That the Door is Uneven and/or Off Track

If your garage door looks crooked or off track in any way, it’s very possible that you're dealing with a broken spring assembly or worn-out cables. As covered in the previous section, you shouldn’t try to fix a broken spring on your own (especially torsion springs). This could cause serious injury, so it’s a job that’s best left to the pros.

Hire a Garage Door Professional

man repairing garage door
Photo: mokee81 / iStock / Getty images

If you’re just doing a garage door tune up, you can safely get away with doing yourself. However, it’s best not to try to DIY repairs if you have a broken garage door. Door repair and replacement is tricky and requires professional knowledge and expertise. Plus, if you just have a minor issue but end up making a mistake in the DIY repair process, you could do more damage and needlessly be on the hook for the full cost of garage door replacement. When it doubt, call in a professional to help solve your problem.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is possible to open a garage door with a broken spring, but it’s not recommended. Doing so could result in serious injury. If you’re in an emergency situation, though, you can pull the emergency release cord to disconnect your garage door opener, and then lift the door manually from the handle, being careful to keep your fingers away from the springs. Since the springs will no longer be there to prevent the door from closing automatcally, you’ll need to have someone put clamps on the tracks under the door once it’s opened to prevent it from slamming shut.

Yes, it’s usually a good idea to replace both garage springs if one breaks for two reasons. First, if one spring breaks because of old age, chances are that the other one isn’t far behind. Replacing both will save time and money. Second, when one spring breaks, it puts excessive and uneven pressure on the other one, which makes damage to the remaining spring more likely. Since you already have a technician coming to repair one, you might as well get both done to save some time and a trip service fee.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to garage door services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
house with blue garage door
Jan 17, 2025
Jan 17, 2025
Want to ensure your home is secure for storm season? We discuss hurricane garage door costs and which factors influence the price tag.
A boy shoots a basketball in front of home’s garage
Jan 7, 2025
Jan 7, 2025
A garage door repair costs less than you might think, considering you can sometimes repair individual panels. However you can’t do many fixes yourself—learn why you need a pro.
Modern garage door
Jan 7, 2025
Jan 7, 2025
The cost of garage door spring replacement depends on the type of spring and garage door you have. Find out what other factors can quickly drive up the price.
Light cottage with garage at frosty and sunny winter
Aug 14, 2024
Aug 14, 2024
Is your garage door frozen shut and preventing access? Use this simple how-to guide to fix the problem and take back your covered parking space.
A beautiful house with a garage and a driveway
Jan 31, 2025
Jan 31, 2025
Does your garage door go up but not down? You might have sensor issues, a broken spring or cable, a malfunctioning opener, or issues with the tracks.
Garage with snow and sleds in front
Aug 9, 2024
Aug 9, 2024
Winterizing your garage door can help you throughout the year, not only in the winter. Using this guide, you’ll learn how adding items such as insulation and even table salt can help prevent your garage door from freezing.
Share project details to get started.