Vinyl vs. Composite Windows: What’s the Difference?
A window into the difference between these materials
Highlights
Vinyl and composite windows are both known for being durable and long-lasting.
Vinyl windows are a budget-friendly choice at $100 to $900 per window.
Composite windows average $300 to $1200 per window.
Vinyl windows last 30 years or more, while composite windows have a life span of more than 40 years.
Windows are one of the hardest-working parts of your home, letting fresh air in and giving you a view of the scenery outside, all while withstanding the elements. When it comes time to replace or install windows, the material you choose can make all the difference. Make sure you understand the differences between vinyl and composite windows before deciding which to use.
Vinyl vs. Composite Windows: Key Differences
Vinyl windows are made of one material—polyvinyl chloride, or PVC—and are a popular choice for new and replacement windows. Composite windows, made of a mix of metal, wood, vinyl, and plastic, have recently become very popular. Both composite and vinyl windows are less expensive than their wood counterparts, but vinyl is far more affordable. However, composite windows are more durable than vinyl and have a longer life span.
What are Vinyl Windows?
Vinyl windows are known for being affordable and low maintenance. These windows come in a wide range of sizes, colors, and frame thicknesses to match your home’s aesthetics.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Affordable | Difficult to customize |
| Low-maintenance | Can be dented and damaged |
| Durable | Can warp in extreme heat |
Best for:
Budget-conscious homeowners
Homes in areas without extreme weather
Pros of Vinyl Windows
When it comes to affordability, vinyl windows can’t be beaten. At an average of $100 to $900 per window, this budget-friendly option is great for homeowners who are watching their bottom line but still want a quality window. Unlike other window frame types, vinyl windows require very little maintenance. Keeping them clean is as simple as washing them with soap and water. Vinyl windows are also long-lasting—you can expect them to last around 30 years or more after installation.
Cons of Vinyl Windows
Vinyl windows come in a variety of colors, but you may run into trouble if you’re looking to change their look, as they’re tricky to paint. While vinyl windows are fairly durable, they can sustain damage from objects or extreme weather like hail. If you live in an area with extremely hot weather, keep in mind that vinyl can warp or discolor in extreme heat, which may mean you’ll need to replace your windows sooner than expected.
What are Composite Windows?
Composite windows are made from a mix of wood, metal (usually aluminum), plastic, and other materials, and the exact makeup of the material can vary by manufacturer. These windows are valued for their durability and longevity and can be made in a variety of finishes, including ones that realistically resemble wood.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Durable | Higher initial cost |
| Low-maintenance | Limited manufacturers |
| More customizable | More expensive to install |
Best for:
Homes in areas with extreme weather
Homeowners looking to invest in “lifetime” windows
Those who like the look of wood windows without the maintenance
Pros of Composite Windows
Composite windows frequently last for 40 years or more, making them pretty hard to beat when it comes to longevity. On top of that, they require very little maintenance beyond periodic washing, and they’re incredibly durable and resistant to impact damage, warping, and fading. They come in various styles and can mimic the look of wood without all the upkeep required by wood.
Cons of Composite Windows
The main drawback to composite windows is the cost. At an average of $300 to $1200 per window, composite windows can be twice as expensive or more than their vinyl counterparts. They’re often more expensive to install, as well. Before buying new windows, you’ll want to contact a local replacement window company to see your options.
Vinyl vs. Composite Windows
| Vinyl | Composite |
|---|---|
| Budget-friendly | Higher upfront cost |
| 30-year life span | 40-year life span |
| Needs more maintenance | More durable |
| Plastic appearance | More customizable |
Appearance: Composite
Vinyl windows can be made in a variety of colors, but they’re always going to retain the look of plastic. Composite windows, however, come in a number of different finishes, including ones that mimic the appearance of wood.
Durability: Composite
Both materials are known for being more durable than other types of windows, like wood or metal. Composite is less susceptible to cracking and damage from impact and is unlikely to warp or discolor due to heat, while vinyl can be damaged by environmental factors more easily.
Energy Efficiency: Tie
Both vinyl and composite windows are highly energy-efficient. With proper installation, both provide superior insulation to other window materials, preventing heat and cooling loss and reducing energy costs over time.
Price: Vinyl
Vinyl windows are much more affordable than composite, often costing half the price. When you’re replacing windows for an entire house, window replacement costs can add up, making vinyl the more budget-conscious choice.
Maintenance: Tie
Both vinyl and composite windows are easy to take care of, especially when compared to high-maintenance materials like wood. Regularly washing your windows with mild soap and water is all you need to do to keep them in great shape for years to come.
Length of Life: Composite
While vinyl windows have an expected life span of around 30 years, composite windows can last 40 years or more and are less likely to need replacement due to damage, making them a great choice for replacement windows.