Is Your Sump Pump Tripping the Breaker? Check for One of These 5 Common Culprits

Pump up the sump pump’s power with proper maintenance

Circuit breaker box
Photo: NC Photo / Adobe Stock
Circuit breaker box
Photo: NC Photo / Adobe Stock
Highlights
  • Sump pumps are most likely to trip the breaker if the motor has to work too hard because of leaks or missing seals.

  • Bad wiring can make a sump pump trip the breaker, and you’ll need a sump pump pro or local electrician to fix this problem.

  • If your pump is damaged beyond reasonable repair, you’ll need to replace it. It costs $525 on average to replace a sump pump.

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

If you keep noticing strange noises in the basement, it’s (probably) not a gremlin. If the noises are accompanied by water flooding the room, there’s a good chance you have a sump pump problem. It’s likely that your sump pump is tripping the breaker time and again. But why? Here are five reasons your sump pump is tripping the breaker and what you can look for before calling the pros.

1. Cracked Housing

Two of the most common types of sump pumps are submersible and pedestal pumps. Submersible sump pumps can short-circuit if even the smallest thing goes wrong since they’re constantly in contact with water. Most commonly, the sump pump's housing can crack over time from normal wear and tear. This causes water to seep in, tripping the breaker.

Visually inspect your sump pump's housing. If it's letting water in, you might be able to just replace the housing. However, the pump itself may need to be replaced if it's water-damaged beyond repair. Call a pro if you’re having trouble figuring out if the housing is to blame. 

2. Faulty Float Switch

A sump pump can trip the circuit breaker if the float switch stops working. The float switch controls the water level, and the switch should rise and fall with each cycle. If the switch stops working properly, it can cause the sump pump to overload or dry-run. This results in the sump pump frequently cycling on and off, which can overload the breaker.

Check the float switch's position and see if it's stuck. Float switches can get stuck or fall apart from age and normal wear and tear.

3. Broken Mechanical Seals

Sump pumps have mechanical seals that keep the pump windings safe. If these seals break, water can get into the pump windings. Seals often break because a bearing gets worn down over time, allowing water to seep in. This can cause the pump shaft to seize and increase the starting current too much, shorting out the circuit breaker.

Check whether the mechanical seals are broken or loose, and call a pro to replace them if needed.

4. Clogged Impeller

Impellers rotate inside the pump to create suction. If the impeller is broken or clogged by debris, mud, gravel, or other materials, the pump has to work much harder to move water to the sump pit. This makes the pump overheat and use more power than normal, causing the circuit breaker to trip.

Check the sump pump's impeller to see if anything is causing a blockage. If a natural disaster just occurred in your area or you’ve recently had some kind of property damage, it's common for the sump pump breaker to keep tripping because of a clog. 

Check that the impeller is free from clogs. You may need to learn how to unclog a sump pump and what its normal operational state should look like.

5. Electrical Issues

Faulty parts, clogs, and leaks are all common signs of overloading. The harder a sump pump has to work, the more likely it is to trip the breaker because the components and wires are overheating. Overheating and overworking cause the motor to draw more current, resulting in a breaker trip. Sump pumps connected to the same circuit as high-power devices will also easily become overloaded. 

Wiring issues are also a common electrical culprit of sump pump shorting. If your home is older, the wires can be worn out from age and decades of use. Additionally, sump pumps that were incorrectly hooked up to the wires can cause the breaker to trip.

If you suspect that electrical issues are the cause of the problem, you should contact a local sump pump installer to correctly diagnose it. They may be able to handle the wiring problems. If your sump pump is connected to the same circuit as another high-power device, a local electrician can create a new circuit for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sump pump failures are more likely to be mechanical than electrical. Before looking into electrical reasons, like bad wiring, check that the float switch isn't stuck in the ON or OFF position so that the sump pump cycles correctly. Check for broken parts, housing, seals, and other parts that may have cracked or come apart due to age and normal wear and tear.

Sump pumps last about 10 years. With regular maintenance, you may be able to get 12 to 15 years out of your sump pump with typical usage. Poorer quality sump pumps may only last six to eight years, and higher quality models will last longer. If you forget about routine sump pump maintenance and inspections, the pump will not have a very long life.

If your basement gets flooded because of a malfunctioning sump pump, most insurance policies won’t cover the damage. You would need to add a rider or endorsement to your policy that covers water damage, which may or may not be an option depending on where you live. However, even with a rider or endorsement that promises to fix flooded basements and replace lost possessions, your sump pump needs to be regularly serviced and maintained to qualify for a payout.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to well and pump services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
hot woman fanning herself at home
Jun 24, 2024
Jun 24, 2024
If you need to bring in an expert to fix a struggling heat pump, this guide breaks down the factors that go into the $165 to $700 you might expect to pay for heat pump repair costs.
Solar powered tube well for irrigation
Nov 22, 2024
Nov 22, 2024
Your solar well pump cost depends on your well depth and flow rate. Explore these cost factors and more to budget for an eco-friendly pump.
water pump in garden
Nov 6, 2024
Nov 6, 2024
Your well tank replacement cost will vary depending on a few key factors, such as the size and capacity of the well pressure tank.
Woman filling glass with tap water
Nov 6, 2024
Nov 6, 2024
Why does well water appear cloudy and bubbly sometimes? Don’t worry. The problem is usually not a major one, but you can always test your water.
mother and little daughter washing their hands
Nov 21, 2023
Nov 21, 2023
Low water pressure is frustrating. That’s why we made this guide to help you learn how to get more pressure from your well for a shower that feels just right.
A woman watering the lawn with a hose
Nov 15, 2024
Nov 15, 2024
Tap into freshwater with a DIY well. Learn how to dig a well by hand with these steps, and enjoy cost savings and a natural water source.
Share project details to get started.