Pool Heater Troubleshooting: 8 Common Issues and How to Solve Them

Dive in (not literally) and fix the issue

A swimming pool in a lush backyard
Photo: Elenathewise / Adobe Stock
A swimming pool in a lush backyard
Photo: Elenathewise / Adobe Stock
Highlights
  • A clogged or dirty filter is the most common culprit for a pool heater malfunction.

  • A low thermostat setting or short timer might also be the issue.

  • Contact a local pool pro for any electrical or gas problems or to replace a part.

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

Your pool heater keeps shutting off or the water is not getting warm, and all you want is to take a dip or swim some laps. Luckily, you can often get a pool heater working again with a little decoding. Dive into our pool heater troubleshooting guide to figure out what might be wrong and when to call in a pool pro.

Why Is My Pool Heater Not Working?

You pool heater is potentially not heating enough due to the following reasons: 

  • Clogged or dirty filter

  • Faulty safety switch or gas valve

  • Thermostat set too low

  • Pilot light issue

  • Closed plumbing valves

  • Lack of power source

  • Damaged wiring

  • Poor ventilation 

  • Outdoor temperature under 60 degrees Fahrenheit

Some of these problems are avoidable, as long as you do not cut corners when budgeting for swimming pool maintenance costs. Additionally, note that your final swimming pool repair costs will vary depending on the issue at hand and whether you are able to do a DIY fix. Either way, we will break down how to solve common issues below.  

1. Pool Heater Keeps Shutting Off

If your pool heater turns on but shuts off soon after, a dirty filter might be the problem. It could also be a safety switch, thermostat setting, or corroded electrical terminal. You can try a variety of solutions to remedy the issue.  

Clean the Filter

Your pool heater needs enough water pressure to run properly, usually at least 40 GPM (gallons per minute). If your heater is not getting a steady stream of water, it could be due to a clogged filter or dirty pump basket. 

Turn off your heater and pump before cleaning. Clean the filter, skimmer, and pump baskets. Remove all removable parts, take out debris, and rinse with a hose before reinstalling the piece. Turn your pool heater back on. If you still do not have enough water pressure, consider checking valves and safety switches. 

Investigate the Safety Switches

Your pool heater might not be working due to a disabled or faulty safety switch. Consult your pool heater manual to determine where the safety switches are. The basic circuit known as the control loop houses the pressure switch, high-limit switch, gas valve, thermostat, and pilot generator. 

If you have experience and comfort working with electrical circuits, there is some troubleshooting you can do. For each switch, check the voltage with a multimeter, being sure to follow safety precautions such as wearing insulated gloves and ensuring the area is dry before testing. Continue checking each switch throughout the control loop until you find the issue. If you find a switch that is not working, use a jumper wire to bypass it, making solid contact with both terminals.

If you do not feel comfortable using a multimeter and working with electrical systems, contact a local pool repair company to assist you.

Adjust the Thermostat

Your pool heater's thermostat might be set too low. Turn it up (at least above the current temperature of the pool) and see if that fixes the problem. If you have an older heater, the contacts in the thermostat might be dirty. Move the knob back and forth to clean the contacts.

Reset the Timer

Your pool heater may need more time to heat the water. Adjust the timer for a longer period and try again.

Consider the Weather

If it is too cold outside, usually less than 60 degrees Fahrenheit, it may be too cold for your heater to run. While some pool heaters can operate in temperatures ranging from 30 degrees Fahrenheit and up, not all do. You may need to wait for warmer weather to run the pool heater.

 A professional repairing a pool heater
Photo: Tomasz Zajda / Adobe Stock

Flip on the Plumbing Valves

The plumbing valves should be open for water to flow to the heater. The valves are located on the connectors between the pipes that lead from the pool to the pump and heater. Check to make sure your plumbing valves are open and connected correctly. 

Clean Off Corrosion 

If you have an electric pool heater, check the electrical terminals for corrosion. Clean any corrosion by first turning off the heater at the power source and then scrubbing the terminals with a metal brush.

Replace Internal Parts

If your pool heater is still not working after troubleshooting other options, you may need to replace a part, such as the pressure switch, high-limit switch, heating element, or motor. 

Contact a local pool pro to inspect your unit. Replacing a part yourself can be tricky and may void any warranties. A pro can also ensure you get a compatible replacement part that will not damage your heater. 

Upgrade Your Pool Pump

If you are running your heater for the first time, the issue could lie with your pool pump. It might not be powerful enough to supply your heater's water pressure. You may want to upgrade the pool pump to a variable-speed pump, but consider other alternatives first or contact a local pool service company to verify the root issue.

Upgrade Your Pool Heater

It is possible your pool heater is not powerful enough for the size of the pool you have. Determine the pool heater size you need based on your pool’s surface area, depth, and volume. Consider installing a new pool heater that optimally heats your pool.

2. Pool Heater Isn’t Turning On

A pool heater in the backyard of a house
Photo: napa74 / Adobe Stock

If your pool heater is not turning on, check the power source and the wiring on your unit. 

Check to See if Heater Is Plugged In and Turned On

Ensure your pool heater is plugged in and turned on and that there are no electrical issues, such as a tripped breaker. Reset the breaker in your electrical panel if needed.

If your pool heater still needs to be fixed, the circuit may need more amperage. A local electrician can assess your amperage and help make any adjustments.

Try the Gas Valve

If you are booting up your pool for the first time this season, the gas supply leading to your heater might be turned off. Turn on the gas valve and retry the pool heater. 

Check the Pilot Light

Without the pilot light, your heater will not fire. To get a closer look, hold a handheld mirror up to it. Never put your face or eyes near the pilot light. 

If there is no spark, you may need to replace your ignition control (you can test it first with a voltmeter to see if it has enough voltage). If you see a spark but the pilot still does not light, you may have a faulty gas valve, clogged pilot assembly, or poor ventilation. Clean the pilot assembly (with the power source turned off at the breaker) if needed, and remove any debris or items that are blocking the vents from proper airflow.  

Look for Damaged Wiring

Check for any damaged wiring on your unit that could be causing a weak electrical connection. If the wiring is damaged, contact the heater’s manufacturer or an electrical company to see if they can repair it. Electrical problems should be handled by a licensed expert, as there can be serious risks involved.

3. Pool Heater Has Error Codes

If you are seeing error codes on your pool heater, use them as clues to determine the root problem.

Decipher Pool Heater Error Codes

Common pool heater error codes such as “Lo/Hi” or “Flo" often mean a water pressure issue. In this case, it is likely that the filter needs cleaning or replacement.

Look in Manufacturer's Manual

If you have the manufacturer's handbook for your pool heater, look at the error code section. It often describes what each code means and how to resolve the issue. If you have misplaced your manual, find the brand and model online to determine what the code means.

4. Pool Heater Is Leaking

A pool heater can sometimes appear to be leaking when it is often just condensation due to a difference in temperatures. But sometimes a pool heater can experience an actual leak.

Look to see if there are any loose connections or leaky gaskets. If there are none, you may need to replace the heat exchanger or install an external bypass to reduce water flow. Certain chemicals used to clean pool water can damage the heat exchanger over time and too much water flow can lead to heater leaks.

5. Pool Heater Will Not Shut Off

If a pool heater will not shut off, it can cause extremely high water temperatures and pose a significant danger. It is best to contact a pool service company right away if this happens.

6. Pool Heater Emits Dark Exhaust or Is Black on Top 

A gas pool heater can expel dark exhaust or be black on top if there is excessive heat. Check the gas pressure on your valve and ensure the heater has proper air ventilation. In some cases, wind or down-drafting can cause poor ventilation. You can install a high wind stack accessory on your pool heater to mitigate this problem. Installation is usually straightforward and can be done as a DIY project.

7. Pool Heater Makes an Unusual Sound

Pool heaters normally make some noise, but anything unusual can indicate a problem you need to fix. A grinding noise could mean there is debris stuck inside the heater which you may be able to fix with a system flush. Or you might have hard water scale buildup in your pool, pipes, or the pool heater exchanger. You will need to get rid of all the calcium deposits, which may require you to call in a pool tech.

Whistling sounds, on the other hand, can reveal a problem with gas pressure. You may need to clean out your burner orifice or adjust the gas pressure valve. A bad pressure switch can also cause grinding or whistling sounds. You may need to replace the switch to get rid of the noise.

8. Pool Will Not Reach Desired Temperature

You are waiting for the water to heat up, but it is taking a long time. If you are noticing that your heater is cycling on and off without the water temperature changing, there are a few potential culprits.

Check that you set the thermostat to the right temperature. If you have a variable-speed pump, make sure that your pump speeds are high enough to kick the heater on. If you are unsure, check the operation manual.

If your pool heater is running but the water is not getting warm, check your filter. If it is dirty, clean it or get a new one. Make sure that the heat exchanger, thermal regulator, pressure sensor, and limit switch are in good, clean working order. 

After all these steps, if you are still stumped, call a technician and ask them to check the electrical connection.

Frequently Asked Questions

You will know that your pool heater has serious issues if, after cleaning the filter, adjusting the thermostat, checking the wiring and power source, and other basic troubleshooting, it still is not warming the water or turns off soon after you turn it on. Minor pool heater repairs and maintenance can fix many issues and increase the life span of your pool heater. But if your pool heater is still not working properly, it might be worth getting a pool heater replacement.

Reset your pool heater by flipping the breaker switch in the electrical panel to “off” and then “on.” Your breaker may be located in a disconnect box near your pool heater or in the breaker panel in your home. If the pool heater still is not turning on, it may be a gas valve, pilot light, safety switch, or water pressure issue.

There are some things you can do to keep your pool heater in good working order. For one, regularly check and balance the water levels. Stay on top of cleaning and maintaining your filters as part of a weekly maintenance checklist. Keep all heater vents cleared of debris, install a surge protector for unexpected outages, and use a solar pool cover when the pool is not in use.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to swimming pool companies
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Infinity pool tile
Mar 6, 2024
Mar 6, 2024
Pool tile costs can vary widely depending on the size of your pool and the type of tile. Here’s how much it costs to retile a pool and other projects to think about.
Family sitting poolside watching the children play
Aug 26, 2024
Aug 26, 2024
When you're long overdue for a pool upgrade, how much does a pool remodel cost? From a new finish to a whole new design, we'll break down your options here.
A swimming pool in tropical garden
Jul 29, 2024
Jul 29, 2024
Thinking about switching from chlorine to salt water in your pool? Learn how much a saltwater pool conversion costs in this informational guide.
Mother and daughter in swimming pool
Feb 7, 2024
Feb 7, 2024
A pool cover protects against debris and temperature changes while also preventing accidents. This guide breaks down the five main types of pool covers to choose from.
Backyard with a swimming pool
Feb 14, 2024
Feb 14, 2024
Need to refill your pool after cleaning or the winter season? Use this guide on how to fill a pool with water for a few different affordable methods.
A family by a swimming pool
Feb 7, 2024
Feb 7, 2024
A pool contractor can turn the pool of your dreams into a reality. Learn how to hire a pool contractor who’s the right match for your project.
Share project details to get started.