Main Lug vs. Main Breaker: What’s the Difference?
Guide the main decision for your electrical system
Highlights
Main lugs connect subpanels, while main breakers control and shut off power for the entire system.
Main breakers provide overcurrent protection, preventing electrical fires; main lugs rely on upstream breakers for safety.
Main breakers can shut off all power simultaneously; main lugs require an external disconnect for complete power shutoff.
Main breakers allow for easy circuit additions; main lugs often require conversion to a main breaker for adding circuits.
Whether you're building a new home or upgrading your electrical system, knowing the difference between a main lug vs. main breaker is key for safety and electrical code compliance. This guide breaks down the key differences to help you choose the best option for your needs.
What Are the Differences Between Main Lugs and Main Breakers?
Main lugs and main breakers serve distinct roles in distributing power throughout an electrical system. However, they operate differently: A main lug acts as a connection point for channeling energy, typically between subpanels, whereas a main breaker controls the different types of circuit breakers throughout a building, allowing power to be shut off at once. Each subpanel connected by a main lug can have its own breakers without a main breaker, while the main lug itself does not include breakers and can’t shut off power simultaneously.
Safety is another major difference between a main lug vs. main breaker. A main breaker connects and disconnects power, plus it acts as a protective shield against overloads and overcurrents. Main lugs don’t have the same built-in protection.
| Type of Difference | Main Lug | Main Breaker |
|---|---|---|
| Application | Connects subpanels | Main power |
| Overcurrent Safety | No protection | Protects |
| Shutoff | Custom by circuit | Shut off all power |
| Installation | More complex | Less complex |
| Code Compliance | Not required | Typically required |
| Adding Circuits | May require upgrade | Easily add circuits |
| Cost | Less expensive | More expensive |
Application Differences
Main lug panels are typically used as subpanels, while main breaker panels are used as the primary electrical panel in a system. Main lug panels are ideal for situations where there is already a main breaker upstream of the current, whereas main breaker panels are best for standalone installations where no other main breaker is present.
Overcurrent Safety Differences
Main breaker panels have a built-in main breaker that provides overcurrent protection for the entire electrical system, which can help prevent electrical fires and other hazards. Main lug panels rely on an upstream breaker for overcurrent protection, which means the safety of the system depends on the correct installation and operation of that upstream device.
Shut-off Differences
A main breaker is the central hub for an entire electrical system, meaning it can simultaneously shut off all circuits for safety or maintenance reasons. Similar to the function of circuit breakers, which cut off power to individual circuits, a main breaker cuts off the entire power supply in buildings. A main lug, on the other hand, cannot cut off all power at once—instead, it requires some sort of external disconnect to shut off power.
Installation Differences
Main breaker panels are easier to install because they include the main breaker within the panel, providing an all-in-one solution. Main lug panels require the installation of an external main disconnect, which can complicate the installation process and increase labor costs.
Electrical Code Compliance Differences
Certain building codes or regulations might mandate installing a main breaker to ensure the safety of a building. Main breaker panels often comply with these codes more easily because they include the necessary main breaker. Conversely, main lug panels may require additional components and upgrades to meet code requirements, depending on local regulations.
Differences in Adding Circuits
Main breakers are easy to adjust and add new circuits, as they already contain a main disconnect to the power supply. Adding circuits to a main lug is more complex, often requiring converting the main lug to a main breaker.
Cost Differences
Main lug panels are less expensive upfront because they do not include a main breaker. However, the overall cost can increase if additional components, such as an external disconnect, are needed to meet safety and code requirements. Replacing an electrical panel costs $520 to $2,120. These components have a higher initial cost but provide a complete solution with built-in protection against overcurrent, which can potentially reduce the long-term costs associated with safety and code compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
While it’s not possible to put a main breaker in a main lug panel, it’s possible to convert a main lug to a main breaker. Converting to a main breaker panel offers increased safety, simplified control, compliance with building codes, and adaptation to changing electrical needs, especially when adding new circuits or upgrading the system.
The key difference between a circuit breaker versus a surge protector is that circuit breakers shield your entire electrical system from overcurrents and faults, while surge protectors defend your electronic devices against voltage surges and spikes. A circuit breaker interrupts the flow of electricity in a circuit when it detects an overload or short circuit, protecting the wiring from damage and preventing fires. In contrast, a surge protector shields electronic devices from voltage spikes, such as those caused by lightning strikes or power surges, preventing damage to the device’s inner mechanics.