How to Remove a Fireplace Insert in 9 Simple Steps

Reimagine your cozy living space

Cozy living room with gas fireplace
Photo: sl-f / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
Cozy living room with gas fireplace
Photo: sl-f / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images
Kate Fann
Written by Kate Fann
Contributing Writer
Updated Dec 19, 2023
SKILL LEVEL
Intermediate
COMPLETION TIME
3 hours
COST
$100–$500
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon
What you'll need:
TOOLS
  • Crowbar or pry bar
  • Screwdriver
  • Wrench
  • Pliers
  • Vacuum cleaner
SUPPLIES
  • Drop cloth
  • Duct tape

A home's fireplace stands as an iconic centerpiece, offering warmth and charm. But, as styles shift and preferences evolve, you may find yourself yearning to bid farewell to your once-cozy fireplace insert. Removing a fireplace insert can be a great project for a handy homeowner looking to revamp their living space. Follow these nine steps, and you'll be on your way to bringing your vision to life.

Prepping to Remove a Fireplace Insert

Taking out a fireplace insert should be approached with caution. The most important safety tip is ensuring the fireplace is not currently in use and that all gas or electrical connections have been turned off. It's also recommended that you review the manufacturer's instructions for your specific fireplace insert, as the removal requirements for different models could vary. If you encounter any challenges, or are uncertain about the process, seek assistance from a local fireplace remodeler.

Read more

  1. Protect the Area

    Couple lays down plastic to protect floor
    Photo: vladans / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    Removing a fireplace insert can cause dust and debris to enter the area. To keep the space as clean as possible, lay down drop cloths to protect the flooring. To prevent debris from entering other areas in your home, tape off vents and open doorways. Protective gloves and safety glasses must be worn, due to the risk of debris in the air. If you choose, you can also wear a mask to prevent debris inhalation. 

  2. Turn Off Utilities

    Hand turning off gas line valve
    Photo: Evgen_Prozhyrko / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    To ensure your safety and that of others around you, turn off any gas, electricity, or other utilities that are connected to the fireplace.

  3. Remove Front Panel

    For fireplace inserts with a decorative front panel or doors, look for any screws or brackets securing them in place. Remove these components. 

  4. Disconnect Gas or Electric Connections

    Technician disconnecting gas fireplace
    Photo: karenfoleyphotography / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    For a gas-powered fireplace, turn off the supply and disconnect it from the line. For an electric fireplace, unplug it from the power source.

  5. Remove the Insert Surround and Trim

    If your fireplace insert has a surround or trim that covers the gap between the insert and the fireplace opening, remove any screws or fasteners securing it and remove.

  6. Detach the Insert

    Technician using electric screwdriver to remove fireplace insert
    Photo: Sinenkiy / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    Using a screwdriver or wrench, remove any screws or brackets securing the fireplace insert. Then, use a crowbar or pry bar to carefully loosen the insert from the fireplace opening. This step should be done at a gradual speed to prevent damage while looking out for any other connections.

  7. Disconnect Venting

    For a vented fireplace, disconnect the vent pipe from the insert. Loosen the clamps or screws using a wrench or pliers. 

  8. Extract the Insert

    Technician extracting fireplace insert out of fireplace opening
    Photo: Sinenkiy / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

    Confirm that all connections are detached. Then, carefully slide or lift the fireplace insert out of the fireplace opening. Take the insert outside of the room and place it in a garage or outdoors. Depending on the type of fireplace insert, it may be quite heavy, so you may need assistance moving it. Then, use a vacuum to remove any debris or soot that is in the fireplace opening and its surrounding area.

  9. Properly Dispose of The Insert

    Before disposing of your fireplace insert, check local regulations to ensure that you follow the appropriate disposal method. Recycling options may be available for certain materials, while others may require a specific disposal method.

DIY vs Hiring a Pro

When dealing with a straightforward electric fireplace insert, homeowners with experience in the removal or similar tasks may be able to undertake the task themselves. However, gas fireplace inserts or more complex installations require hiring a professional fireplace remodeler for a safer and more efficient handling.

Trained fireplace technicians possess the know-how to deal with potential complications, ensure the appropriate disconnection of gas or electrical lines, and ensure a smooth removal process. Safety is of utmost importance when working with fireplaces, and the likelihood of errors or mishandling of components is diminished when relying on experienced remodelers. Additionally, hiring a professional could save time and effort while ensuring that the job is completed correctly and in accordance with safety regulations.

The cost to remove a fireplace insert averages $1,500. If you're planning to do away with your fireplace entirely, the cost to remove a fireplace ranges between $500 and $4000. If this is your end-goal, hiring a professional is your best bet so they can complete the job from top to bottom.

Frequently Asked Questions

Although no heating appliance can be entirely risk-free, a fireplace insert is considered a safer alternative to a traditional open fireplace, thanks to their enclosed design. With a sealed combustion chamber, a fireplace insert effectively reduces the risk of sparks and embers escaping into the room, minimizing the chance of an accidental fire.

Additionally, an insert comes equipped with various safety features, such as tempered glass doors that create a barrier between the flames and the surrounding space. This enhances both safety and energy efficiency by preventing heat loss. As an added bonus, many inserts are designed to meet strict safety standards that ensure proper ventilation and combustion.

With a little ingenuity, an old fireplace insert can be transformed into a decorative centerpiece that infuses new life into any room. Consider placing LED lights or candles inside to create a captivating display that simulates the warm glow of a fire. Another option is to repurpose the insert as a charming bookshelf by adding rustic shelves within the firebox. For plant lovers, converting the fireplace insert into an indoor garden is a perfect way to bring nature indoors. You can also transform it into a stylish wine rack.

Installing a fireplace insert can be complicated and expensive, particularly if modifications are necessary to accommodate it. The cost of purchasing an insert and necessary venting system can also be a significant investment. Fuel type may also be limited with gas or electric inserts, potentially reducing the cozy appeal of a traditional wood-burning fireplace. Maintenance and repair may require specialized services, especially when dealing with gas lines or electrical components. Some argue that fireplace inserts lack the authentic ambiance of an open, crackling fire, with glass doors potentially reducing the visual appeal of the flames.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
Learn more about our contributor
Kate Fann
Written by Kate Fann
Contributing Writer
Kate Fann is a content writer with ten years of online writing experience, taking a specialized focus on strategic SEO.

The homeowners guide to fireplace services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles