11 Classic Craftsman Exterior Paint Colors

Think of the colors on the most beautiful fall day: orange, yellow, and brick red foliage; black or gray tree trunks; blue sky with white clouds; brown or beige dirt; and green evergreens. These hues should be your inspiration when picking the perfect exterior paint color for your Craftsman-style house. Here are a few color schemes to consider.

1. Blue and White

Ask your local painter to coat your home a deep blue color and paint the trim white, evoking a cloudy sky. This nautical color scheme is particularly fitting for homes in coastal areas and works beautifully with facades featuring stone elements.

Recommended colors:

• Sherwin-Williams Bunglehouse Blue with Sherwin-Williams Pure White

• Benjamin Moore Schooner with Benjamin Moore Palest Pistachio 

2. Greens

Choose two of the same type of greens (mint, olive, sage, or hunter), one lighter and another darker. To make your color scheme cohesive, try two colors from the same swatch stick in different saturations so there’s enough contrast. Then paint the trim in white or cream.

Recommended colors:

• Valspar Blanched Thyme with Valspar Mint Frost

• Sherwin-Williams Broccoflower with Sherwin-Williams Greenfield

3. Taupe and Green

Mix a brown-gray color with sage, olive, or mint green trim. The green trim will pop, giving your facade a more finished, dynamic look. This color scheme works particularly well with homes with large trees in the yard, as it ties them to their natural surroundings.

Recommended colors:

• Benjamin Moore Thicket with Benjamin Moore Sparrow  

• Benjamin Moore Saybrook Sage with Benjamin Moore Copley Gray 

4. Green and Brown

For a truly organic feel, choose green and brown with a natural stain front door. For more visual interest, go with a front door stain that’s noticeably darker or lighter than the brown you pick for your body color. When selecting your green and brown, either opt for colors with a similar or opposite saturation, depending on whether you’re going for contrast. 

Recommended colors:

• Valspar Sweet Serenity with Valspar Fired Earth  

• Behr Royal Orchard with Behr Chocolate Therapy 

5. Beige and White

This neutral color scheme will give your home an airier, more luminous look. For a more classic Craftsman feel, your beige should feature noticeable undertones of yellow or brown. Since this color scheme is subtle, it can work best for homes with eye-catching architecture.   

Recommended colors:

• Behr Baja with Behr Swiss Coffee

• Benjamin Moore Shaker Beige with Benjamin Moore Mountain Peak White

6. Gray and Green

For a dramatic and elegant facade, try a dark gray for the body color and a light mint or sage green for the trim color, with a natural stain front door. To emphasize the green, plant bushes near your front door. This palette is sophisticated and modern so you can give your home an update.

Recommended colors:

• Valspar Grey Suit with Valspar Mint Whisper

• Benjamin Moore Gray 2121-10 with Benjamin Moore Soft Fern   

7. Green and Yellow

With this approach, go for two complementary colors for subtle contrast and a soft look. The resulting effect is cheery and elegant. To avoid color overload, opt for a front door with a natural wood stain.

• Sherwin-Williams Dancing Green with Sherwin-Williams Convivial Yellow

• Farrow & Ball Breakfast Room Green with Farrow & Ball Hay

8. Green and Cream

This color scheme is similar—just with slightly more contrast. By opting for cream rather than yellow, you’ll give your green more of a starring role. So take your time picking the right hue for your facade.

Recommended colors:

• Sherwin-Williams Majolica Green with Sherwin-Williams Oyster White

• Behr Roof Top Garden with Behr Unwind 

9. Yellow and Cream

Try a light yellow for the body color and cream for the trim. This color scheme works wonders for homes with stucco facades. To add an element of surprise, consider a front door painted dark blue or green roof shingles.

Recommended colors:

• Farrow & Ball Dorset Cream with Farrow & Ball White Tie

• Farrow & Ball Day Room Yellow with Farrow & Ball Wimborne White   

10. Gray and Orange

For a dynamic, modern look, pick this eye-catching combo. It best suits clapboard facades that feature some natural stone elements. To carry on the orange theme, place orange planters by your front door or opt for other outdoor accessories in amber hues.

Recommended colors:

• Valspar Stone Mason Gray with Valspar Imperial Gold

• Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal with Benjamin Moore Hale Orange   

11. Red

If you want to make a statement, go red. To play up the drama, you can even paint both the body color and trim the same hue. For some contrast, go with a natural wood stain for the front door. When it comes to picking a red, know that brick varieties are popular for Craftsman-style homes. 

Recommended colors:

• Behr Chianti 

• Sherwin-Williams Antique Red

Cost to Paint Your House Exterior 

The average cost to paint your home’s exterior professionally is $3,145, typically ranging from $1,810 to $4,500. You’ll find numerous fluctuations in the costs, though, depending on several factors, including the size of your home, the number of stories, and the type of siding. Additional add-on paint projects, such as painting trim, garage doors, windows, and gutters, will also impact the overall cost.

DIY vs. Hiring a Pro

Painting the exterior of the home is possible as a DIY and can save you a tremendous amount of money. The cost of materials to DIY exterior painting is $500 to $1,000. However, painting an exterior requires a wide range of materials, including the paint, applicators, drop sheets, and a ladder that can extend to the top of your siding. A professional exterior painter will have the gear to do the job safely.

Sara Coleman contributed to this article.