8 Tips for How to Negotiate With Your Contractor

Negotiating doesn't have to be scary, especially when you follow these tips

Refrigerator repairman
Photo: sefa ozel / E+ / Getty Images
Refrigerator repairman
Photo: sefa ozel / E+ / Getty Images
Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

Some contractors are willing to negotiate their price, and others won't budge. But how do you negotiate with contractors-  and get a better deal? Rest assured, there are some steps you can take to get the best bid on your home project.

1. Shop Around for the Best Price-to-Quality Contractor

Shopping around never hurts and ensures you get a fair assessment of the project's cost before signing a contract. Knowing how to save money on your home improvement projects is always a good idea. That's why it's essential to ask for at least three to four bids before deciding on the price you're willing to pay for the project.

When you gather estimates, you can always negotiate the cost of the project with any contractor. Many general contractors are willing to negotiate their prices and terms if they're competing for a job.

It is helpful to be up-front with contractors and let them know what you expect from the process:

  • Prepare to answer the contractor’s questions, as this will help craft a more exact estimate

  • To ensure the accuracy of the bids they provide, only offer contractors as many details about your project as they need

  • Have a running list of qualified contractors and company numbers ready to go; this will come in handy for future home projects

2. Research the Contractors You’re Looking to Hire

Before you hire a contractor, it's always a good idea to verify a company’s credentials including licensing, bonding, and insurance. Read reviews, look at their work, and ask for references from past clients.

In some cases, you may find that working with a tradesperson with less experience will be more affordable. Just make sure you're comfortable with their level of experience.

Researching the cost of your materials also helps when negotiating with a contractor. For example, you may notice that your contractor only buys the most expensive lumber rather than a more affordable option.

It's wise to keep a list whenever a contractor gives you estimates on materials necessary to supply the project. You'll then know for sure if they're making exorbitant purchases, and you’ll have leverage during negotiations. 

3. Pick the Right Time of Year for Better Prices

Plumber fixing toilet
Photo: Navinpeep / Moment / Getty Images

Depending on the season, general contractors may be more willing to negotiate for a lower price. To save money, compare cost estimates from various companies during the slower seasons (winter or summer, depending on your project).

For example, if you live in a colder climate you should wait until the winter to call contractors for estimates.

4. Offer to Save Money by Purchasing Supplies and Materials Yourself

When hiring a contractor, you may pay for subcontractors or material supplies directly. Most contractors offer to purchase the supplies you need for the project and include their cost estimate in the contract or bill you for them later. The contractor usually already has a supplier they like, so prices can be high due to convenience.

One way to successfully negotiate with general contractors is to focus on the supplies required for a project. Offer to buy these materials yourself. Just remember to double check the quantities in advance with your contractor so you don't run out mid-project.

5. Always Be Polite, but Firm When Negotiating With Contractors

You should always be polite when trying to negotiate a contract, but don’t be afraid to speak confidently. The tone of your voice can help persuade someone to agree with you, so make sure it's not too aggressive or passive—even if you're frustrated.

You want them to respect your authority in this situation. It will make it easier for the contractor to come down in price.

6. Present Options Before Asking for a Price

Tell the contractor what you need from them. Then ask them to give their best possible estimate, and they'll know how much work is involved before providing an answer.

Explain in detail the timeframe for your repair. Very few general contractors will quote you a price more than three months out. But if you're looking to close within a couple of weeks, then mention that to avoid any delays. Let them know they're not your only option, either, by telling them you're collecting a few other quotes.

Ask when the contractor is available and how long it’ll take to complete the work. As you talk to each contractor, ask questions about the job requirements and take notes. Knowing what you need helps you find a match for your home repair needs.

7. Build a Rapport With the Contractor and Show Them Mutual Respect

Don't approach the pricing situation as if the contractor is against you. Otherwise, it will reflect negatively on your relationship with them. Instead, treat the contractor as your ally in finding a lower price for your home improvement project.

Show them you respect their professional authority by asking for any changes you could make to the project to help save money. For example, they might be able to make some substitutions, such as using more affordable materials.

8. Don't Be Discouraged if They Say No at First

Learning how to negotiate with contractors takes time and compromise. You may need to walk away and potentially come back. Get free estimates from other contractors that are slightly lower than the current bid you're considering.

This information may make your general contractor reconsider and propose a more competitive offer. Or, it could leave them with no option but to lower their price.

How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Contractor?

The average cost to hire a general contractor is $4,000, but this figure varies widely based on the type and scope of the project. Extensive projects requiring multiple workers cost more than quick projects one person can complete. Instead, a more accurate way to estimate the hiring cost is based on a percentage of the overall project cost. 

General contractors typically charge customers 10% to 20% of the cost of a project​​. For example, if it costs $20,000 to remodel a kitchen, a contractor will likely charge between $2,000 and $4,000 for the job. Some contractors operate on a per-day basis, with an average rate between $300 and $500 per day.

When Should I Hire a Contractor?

It’s worth hiring a local contractor for projects that are time-consuming, complicated, or dangerous to do yourself. This includes anything from fence installation to home renovation. However, you may prefer to hire a handyperson for small tasks like installing a light fixture or fixing a leak. General contractors have the licensure and experience to handle large-scale projects, but a handyperson can complete simple household projects at a cheaper rate.

Frequently Asked Questions

From common courtesies to ensuring you’re getting a fair deal, here are a few things to avoid saying to a contractor:

  • Don’t tell a contractor they’re the only one bidding for the job

  • Don’t ask for a discount by attempting to pay entirely up front

  • Don’t say there’s no hurry to complete the project

  • Don’t recommend subcontractors whom you’ve worked with before

  • Don’t ask a contractor to work in hazardous conditions

A down payment of 50% is abnormally high for contract work. While not unheard of, the average down payment is 10% to 25% of the project. It may be a red flag if a contractor asks for 50% up front or is unwilling to negotiate the percentage. Many states cap down payments at specific percentages and figures. In California, for example, down payments are capped at 10% of the contract price or $1,000—whichever is less.

If a contractor’s estimate leaves you scratching your head, the best way to tell if the price is fair is by comparing quotes from other contractors for the same project. Don’t mention the current bid beforehand; simply request a quote and compare the figures. A few other red flags are when contractors communicate poorly, refuse to provide proof of insurance, ask homeowners to obtain permits, have no reviews or primarily negative reviews, or request excessive down payments, particularly in cash.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to unfinished carpentry services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
senior woman in stair lift seat
Nov 1, 2024
Nov 1, 2024
Use our guide to calculate the cost to install a stair lift in your home. Prices depend on the type of stair lift, including the seat style and other advanced features.
a brick wall and wood floor room with black modern reading chair and lamp, ottoman, and bookshelf with ladder
Jul 22, 2024
Jul 22, 2024
Brick walls can add character and elegance to interior and exterior spaces. Use this brick wall cost guide to see the price range for adding one to your home.
A land with grass and trees
Nov 7, 2024
Nov 7, 2024
Going from an undeveloped plot to your dream home can be expensive. Learn about the cost to develop land and what factors can affect your total.
Homeowner and contractor go over job
Dec 10, 2024
Dec 10, 2024
How much do you pay a contractor up front? Many states cap how much a contractor can ask for before work begins. Here’s what you need to know.
A senior couple at their home
Nov 25, 2024
Nov 25, 2024
Aging in place is a lifestyle for seniors who prefer living in the comfort of their homes as they age, but what is aging in place? Keep reading to find out.
Homeowner talks to contractor
Dec 12, 2024
Dec 12, 2024
What should you do when a contractor does poor work? Your best defense is documentation. Here's how to fight back and hopefully turn your project around.
Share project details to get started.