8 Warning Signs You Need New Gutters

To determine if you need new gutters, you may only have to look up at your home

A gutter filled with autumn leaves
Photo: Willowpix / E+ / Getty Images
A gutter filled with autumn leaves
Photo: Willowpix / E+ / Getty Images
Highlights
  • Properly functioning gutters are critical to avoid water damage to your home’s exterior.

  • Cracks, peeling paint, and rust are a few of the common signs your gutters need replacing.

  • A full gutter replacement costs on average $1,900.

Get quotes from up to 3 pros!
Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you.
Geo Icon

Your gutter system is one of the many unsung heroes of your house, preventing a rainy day from becoming a major annoyance. Although most gutters can last for 20 years, eventually, you may have to replace them, especially if they’ve been looking a little worse for wear lately. But knowing when to make the call to opt for a gutter replacement can be tough, which is why we’ve compiled these eight signs you may need new gutters.

1. Cracks

While small cracks in your gutters may not seem like a big issue, if not repaired quickly, they will become more prominent and cause further damage to your gutters. These imperfections can damage the fascia boards behind the gutters, the shingles above the gutter, and the foundation below. 

Contacting a local gutter repair pro can help you determine which cracks you can easily repair and when it’s time to replace the entire system.

2. Peeling Paint

The paint on your gutter should be able to withstand typical wear and tear throughout the seasons, from things like snow and crunchy leaves. However, if your gutters are old, peeling paint or orange flecks indicate continuous standing water. This peeling could signify that the gutter is not removing water or that cracks or other damage may be present, requiring a replacement sooner rather than later.

3. Pools of Water or Mildew

Keeping your gutter and downspouts clean play a key role in preventing your gutters from aging prematurely and failing to drain properly. Gutters should keep water flowing away from your home’s foundation. If you notice pools of water or mildew near the foundation, it can indicate that the gutters are not working as intended. This issue could be caused by something as simple as a clog or something as complex as a defect in the system from incorrect gutter installation. 

It’s important to diagnose this problem quickly as water in your gutters can easily cause foundation damage, leading to costly, time-consuming repairs. If you have an older home with 4-inch gutters, and you decide to replace them, you should opt for 5-inch gutters to help with water flow.

4. Water Damage or Water Marks Directly Beneath the Gutters

Check your gutters at least once a year on a day that’s relatively sunny and free from rain. Water damage or marks underneath the gutter indicate that leaking or overflowing water is escaping the gutter. This type of water intrusion can damage your soffit and fascia board, so it’s important to get the problem taken care of quickly.

5. Gutters Sag or Pulling Away From the House

A man cleaning the gutter from leaves
Photo: Photographee.eu / Adobe Stock

This sign is one of the easiest ways to tell that you need gutter repairs or gutter replacement because you don’t need to be on a ladder to notice it. Gutters should never sag or divert away from your home, and this movement can indicate that they are full of water and pulling away due to the weight. 

When your gutter is full of water, it could mean that your system isn’t appropriate for your home, it’s draining improperly, or debris is causing a blockage. Sagging gutters could require high costs or be a hassle to repair, which is why removing and replacing your gutters may be more worth it.

6. Breaks at the Seams

Your gutters should always be joined together with an airtight seal. When that is broken or damaged, you risk leaks and other damage. While you can perform the occasional repair, if you’re noticing frequent breaks in the seams between gutters, you should think about replacing your gutters once and for all.

7. Rust

Eroding metal is one of the most obvious indicators that it’s time for a new gutter system. Large rust spots can compromise your gutters’ integrity. Again, you can repair the occasional small rusty spot, but if you’re noticing large areas, it’s worth calling a local gutter installation pro to explore your replacement options.

8. Fallen Nails or Fasteners

Hardware like fasteners, nails, and screws keep your gutters in place and tight to your roof and fascia, respectively. Repair what you can, but if you’re constantly picking these metal pieces up off of the ground, it could be time for a gutter replacement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Most gutters last between 20 to 50 years, depending on the quality of material you choose. Aluminum will last on average 25 years, while higher end options like zinc or copper last 50 years. Proper installation and maintenance have the biggest impact on on the lifespan of your gutters.

New gutters cost on average $1,900 for an average sized home, but can cost much more depending on your house size. Gutters are a basic necessity for homes in order to keep water from pooling around your house and damaging the exterior. It’s also a project that can last for many decades with minimal ongoing costs (especially if you’re able to clean gutters yourself). While an expensive upfront cost, the decades long lifespan and low maintenance costs make it a worthwhile investment.

Need professional help with your project?
Get quotes from top-rated pros.
The homeowners guide to gutter repair contractors
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
A modern home with green grass and trees in front yard
Aug 23, 2024
Aug 23, 2024
Wondering how much gutter installation costs? We’ll break down prices by material, gutter type, and other factors impacting overall gutter costs.
Zinc gutter installed on the roof of a house
Jan 4, 2024
Jan 4, 2024
Learn about the average cost of zinc gutters when having new gutters installed at your home. Long-lasting zinc gutters can cost twice as much as aluminum gutters.
grey home with shingles and gutters
Aug 14, 2024
Aug 14, 2024
Are gutter guards worth it? The average gutter guard installation cost is $650 to $2,000 but varies depending on types, materials, home height, and other factors.
Copper gutters with nature in the background
Mar 21, 2024
Mar 21, 2024
To determine what copper gutters cost, consider factors like the size of your home and the style of gutters you want. Here’s how to price out your project.
A new beige house
Mar 21, 2024
Mar 21, 2024
This guide will give you an idea of how much you can expect to pay when getting new seamless gutters installed when accounting for removal, labor, and different gutter materials.
Aluminum rain gutters installed on a suburban house
Mar 5, 2024
Mar 5, 2024
Copper gutters vs. aluminum gutters can be a tough call, but price, appearance, and longevity may steer you one way or the other. Keep reading to see how.
Share project details to get started.